[問題] 一題邏輯問題

看板GRE (GRE入學考試)作者 (bluewed)時間10年前 (2015/06/04 15:07), 10年前編輯推噓5(506)
留言11則, 6人參與, 最新討論串1/1
有一題邏輯問題跟同學討論很久,還是無法理解答案跟題目關聯性 題目: Police found that ninety percent of the burglaries and attempted burglaries ov er a five-year period in the city of Crowther occured in houses that did not h ave burglar alarm system. The police concluded that, in Crowther, the presence of a burglar alarm system is usually effective as a deterrent to burglary. The conclusion reached by the police presupposes which of the following? (A) The burglars entered houses only when they thought the occupants were away or asleep. (B)The burglars entered houses that had burglar alarm systems only when they a nticipated finding particularly valuable goods. (C) When they entered a house that had no burglar alarm system, the burglars c ould take more time to search for valuables. (D) Before they entered a house, the burglars could usually tell whether or no t it had a burglar alarm system. (E) The difference in the burglary rate between houses that had burglar alarm systems and those that did not have remained constant during the five-year per iod 答案是(C),可是我們覺得(D)的答案比較有關聯性,有請大家幫忙解答了。謝謝 -- Sent from my Android -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 101.14.114.138 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/GRE/M.1433401629.A.C8C.html ※ 編輯: genkibb74142 (101.14.114.138), 06/04/2015 15:07:47

06/04 15:50, , 1F
結論是防盜裝置可以有效震懾竊賊所以C是說竊賊們若
06/04 15:50, 1F

06/04 15:51, , 2F
沒看到就敢繼續偷(找有價值的)並沒提到可先分辨有無
06/04 15:51, 2F

06/04 15:54, , 3F
因此D無關而C可能可以被這樣認為
06/04 15:54, 3F

06/04 17:04, , 4F
D沒關係吧?知不知道是否有警報器和偷不偷沒直接關係
06/04 17:04, 4F

06/04 17:04, , 5F
,原po或許有些過度延伸選項所沒提供的資訊?C選項
06/04 17:04, 5F

06/04 17:04, , 6F
符合做為警報器與偷竊率兩者間的連結
06/04 17:04, 6F

06/04 23:54, , 7F
謝謝兩位的解答,邏輯真是微妙的東西..
06/04 23:54, 7F

06/05 00:31, , 8F
這題是1990年的GRE考古題,官方答案是 (D)不是(C)
06/05 00:31, 8F

06/05 00:32, , 9F
請原po以及樓上各位注意一下,不要解錯了、想錯了
06/05 00:32, 9F

06/05 21:47, , 10F
難怪我覺得怪怪的!
06/05 21:47, 10F

06/06 07:52, , 11F
哈哈 本來想說是D XDD
06/06 07:52, 11F
文章代碼(AID): #1LR_aToC (GRE)
文章代碼(AID): #1LR_aToC (GRE)