[期刊] 投稿經驗分享 APL+JAP
1. 領域: nanoscale heat transfer
2. 期刊名稱: Applied Physics Letters
3. 被accepted/revised/rejected : rejected
4. 投稿後大約多久才收到結果:
submission date: 2009-01-14
decision: 2009-01-25 （letter類講求時效性，所以一般來說兩星期內就有結果）
5. reviewer的數目(comment數目)：1
被退稿的原因如下（節錄自comment）：
While the results are interesting and useful, and should be published, they
are not significantly novel nor important to be published in Applied Physics
Letters. The manuscript could, however, be published as a regular article in
the Journal of Applied Physics.
所以我們就從善如流寫成paper並改投到JAP，然後在cover letter裡把這段話抄上去XD
（你看，是貴期刊的姊妹刊叫我們轉投的哦）
1. 領域: nanoscale heat transfer
2. 期刊名稱: Journal of Applied Physics
3. 被accepted/revised/rejected : accepted (publish as is)
4. 投稿後大約多久才收到結果:
submission date: 2009-02-25
decision: 2009-04-16
5. reviewer的數目(comment數目)：1
我想APL reviewer的那段話蠻有幫助的，所以連revision都不用就接受了:P
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.112.46.71
推
09/02 20:11, , 1F
09/02 20:11, 1F
推
09/02 20:52, , 2F
09/02 20:52, 2F
→
09/02 20:57, , 3F
09/02 20:57, 3F
推
09/02 21:11, , 4F
09/02 21:11, 4F
推
09/03 13:45, , 5F
09/03 13:45, 5F
→
09/03 13:46, , 6F
09/03 13:46, 6F
→
09/03 13:47, , 7F
09/03 13:47, 7F
推
09/03 14:34, , 8F
09/03 14:34, 8F
※ fuhshuenn:轉錄至看板 NTUfinDr 09/13 23:27
PhD 近期熱門文章
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章
-4
12
