Re: [問題] 投ASME尋問Editor目前進度的回覆代表意 …

看板PhD (博士班)作者QPQP530 (永不放棄)時間15年前 (2010/12/17 18:17)推噓2(2推 0噓 2→)

留言4則, 3人參與討論串1/1

上次尋問ASME的進度,今天的AE已經寄信給我,狀況已從paper under review改成 AE recommendation...也寫了E-mail給我如下... Dear OOO, Review of your paper, OOO(Research Paper), your paper has been completed and my recommendation has been sent to the Editor. An email from the Editor informing you of his decision will be the next email communication that you receive. The detailed comments of the reviewers and my recommendation will be available to you through your author account when the Editor makes their decision. Thank you for submitting your work to the Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control. Sincerely, XXX Associate Editor, XXX 不知從這段文字可以看出文章的最後決定為何?是拒絕或接受或修改後接受? 心情真的七上八下....煩請有經驗前輩可以告知或給點研判的經驗..謝謝各位了! ※ 引述《QPQP530 (永不放棄)》之銘言： : 投ASME已經快五個月了,都一直在paper under review的狀況,老闆說可以寫信問問 : 今天有回應如下... : Thank you for your mail message regarding paper. Two of the three reviews : have been submitted by the external reviewers. The third one due on : November 15 and I am hopeful that the last reviewer will meet this : target date. There was some additional time required in the identification : of reviewers for this article given the technical content. : 三個審稿人員,兩個已經完成,還在等第三個的回覆,想問的是,既然兩個都已經審稿 : 完畢,如果兩個都接受應該可以直接回覆接受或修改後接受,但Editor卻一定要等第三 : 個審稿員回覆才要回覆,這是不是代表已經被拒絕了呢?還是仍有其它的可能性?不知 : 投過ASME有經驗的前輩認為呢?還望不吝賜教. -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.57.107.9