[分享]SK2-VVN:你用過新制寫作的AI Rater了嗎？

看板TOEFL_iBT (TOEFL_iBT托福)作者ovivian3 (大V)時間1年前 (2023/08/24 00:23)推噓0(0推 0噓 0→)

留言0則, 0人參與討論串1/1

PTT托福板友們大家好，我是SK2 TOEFL實力養成班教學顧問Vivian. 9月是暑假完成課程同學們首戰托福的重要月份，若距離考試剩2-3週，我會叮嚀大家要開始練習計時的臨場感。 ETS因應新制托福上路開發了一些不錯的工具，其中寫作Task 2有非常接近正式考試UI的介面可以練官方釋出的練習題與計時，更能使用AI Rater評分作文。 Task 2練習介面在這裡： https://www.ets.org/toefl/test-takers/ibt/prepare/practice-tests.html 近日有很多認真的學生拿AI評估的結果與我討論，我們來看看不同分數區間的差異：題目： Which approach do you think is better: Giving grades based only on performance, or grading students not just on performance but also on their effort? 以下為學生10分鐘內寫完的版本；可能有under timed conditions的typo. (AI Score: 4.0) In my opinion, Kelly is right when she said that a perfromance based evaluation is more reasonable. It is by far the most efficient and recognizable way of grading, consider evaluating ones effort is abstract and time-consuming. I'd added that students' effort will show on their grades under most of the conditions. On the contrary, when a student doesn't really put effort into their work, their performance will definitely have many errors. When a hard-working student spend hours on assignments or tests to completely figure out what are the core comcept and correct answer, they can get good performance easily based on their hard work. That is to say, I think evaluating with performance without considering effort is fair and benefits students learning curve. Other than considering students' side, it is more managable for teacher to grade students based on identical criteria that is quantfiable. 再來是修改過後的版本，這次AI給Score of 5.0: In my opinion, Kelly is right when she said that a perfromance based evaluation is more reasonable. It is by far the most common way of grading, consider evaluating ones effort is time-consuming and hard to quantifiable. I'd added that students' effort will show on their grades under most of the conditions. When a hard-working student spend hours on assignments to completely figure out the concepts and tips on finishing it, they can get good result easily based on their what they've learned. On the contrary, when students don't really put effort into works, their result would have many errors and they don't really learn stuff. For example, I usually start preparing for an exam 2 weeks before, but once I forgot to mark an upcoming exam on my calander. The time that I found out and started to study was 3 days before it. Not having enough preparation bought me terrible result on that exam, for sure. To sum up, I think grading without counting effort is fair and resonable. 不知道同學們看不看得出來兩個版本的差異呢？ ETS在相同網頁中提供了scoring guide給大家參考： 4.0-5.0區間： You made a well-supported, relevant contribution to the discussion, and your ideas are easy to understand. Weaknesses, if there are any, might have to do with: -use of English that is occasionally ungrammatical, unclear or unidiomatic -the elaboration of your viewpoint needing a little more detail or explanation 以上內容兩者最大不同是，5.0的版本多了「舉例」，而且其中兩句重新排列，使邏輯較為通順。 AI是根據ETS公布的標準評分的，因此所有考生應該都要對於Rubrics瞭若指掌： https://www.ets.org/pdfs/toefl/toefl-ibt-writing-rubrics-enhanced.pdf 換句話說，只要充分了解題目的requirements與評分rubrics標準，同學們將對練習方向會清楚不少。當然ETS最後給分還要經過人工審核，所以同學們使用這個AI工具只能當成初步分析自我表現的工具；詳細的feedback（是否切題、更進一步的改善建議）還是要由有經驗的老師們給予。＊＊＊想要詳細的feedback、或是不知道該如何下筆的同學們，在這裡當然要推薦我們的托福課程囉！ SK2 TOEFL「托福實力養成班」協助弱底同學打底、並針對新制托福設計完整課程。 -報名即送課前手冊，搶先預習六大學科分類字彙 -按照上課進度出作業，提供個別批改建議 -每週多場次顧問時間，課後仍可享有永久免費諮詢資源 -專屬Line社群，揪到最合拍的讀書會夥伴＊課程線上諮詢官方Line@：@sk2toefl https://lin.ee/wSQghNS ＊實力養成班最新課表：https://lurl.cc/Jj7op3 ＊線上報名表單：https://forms.gle/ixJuDKQFFMBvxZy67 ＊＊＊＊＊＊＊歡迎加入 #高分人數全台北第一 Mason GRE 臉書社團 https://www.facebook.com/groups/GRE340/ SK2 TOEFL Consultant Group 顧問專欄、實力養成班/衝刺班課程&預約試聽資訊 http://SK2toefl.blogspot.com ＊＊＊＊＊＊＊祝福九月份考生們旗開得勝！ Vivian, SK2 TOEFL實力養成班顧問 https://linktr.ee/ovivian3 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 219.70.142.24 (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/TOEFL_iBT/M.1692807833.A.FF9.html