[討論] 男玩3P致死 醫師沒警告判賠9千萬

看板medache (醫療心酸)作者 (哇哈哈)時間13年前 (2012/06/01 18:41), 編輯推噓5(5011)
留言16則, 6人參與, 最新討論串1/1
男玩3P致死 醫師沒警告判賠9千萬 http://www.appledaily.com.tw/realtimenews/article/international/20120601/125375 ________________________________________________ 美國一名男子馬汀尼(William Martinez)在2009年與一男一女玩3P遊戲,引發 心臟病致猝死,馬汀尼死時才31歲。昨日當地法院宣判,馬汀尼的死與他的主 治醫師港嘎沙尼(Dr Sreenivasalu Gangasani)未盡治療責任有關係,引此判 決港嘎沙尼必須賠償馬汀尼家屬300萬美元(約新台幣9千萬元)。 法官認為,馬汀尼曾向港嘎沙尼尋求治療胸痛的問題,港嘎沙尼也為馬汀尼 安排療程,卻沒有告知馬汀尼禁止做「激烈運動」,導致馬汀尼在玩3P時致死, 因此港嘎沙尼必須負擔未告知的醫療責任,判賠300萬美金。港嘎沙尼 的代表律師表示仍會再上訴。 ________________________________________________ 31歲的胸痛病人..... 美國的判決越來越誇張,而台灣又常跟著美國, 偏偏島上的醫療是不能把法律風險提列成本轉嫁給病人的, 以後連看門診都可能吃上一堆奇怪的醫療糾紛大概也不會太意外 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ※ 編輯: hahawow 來自: 123.192.156.57 (06/01 18:44)

06/01 18:51, , 1F
推最後註解 這就是鬼島跟台灣的差別
06/01 18:51, 1F

06/01 18:51, , 2F
錯了 這就是鬼島跟美國的差別 XD
06/01 18:51, 2F

06/01 19:36, , 3F
很誇張嗎?我倒覺得鬼島醫師因為沒讓自己去撞樹,到院時昏迷指數
06/01 19:36, 3F

06/01 19:37, , 4F
只剩四分的病患恢復成活蹦亂跳要賠三千多萬更誇張
06/01 19:37, 4F

06/01 19:43, , 5F
這個病人死亡就九千萬,如果變植物人......
06/01 19:43, 5F

06/01 19:44, , 6F
而且人家收費標準跟鬼島一樣,只不過一個是USD,一個是NTD
06/01 19:44, 6F

06/01 19:45, , 7F
以後即使低冠心病風險的胸痛,可能都要告知禁止激烈運動
06/01 19:45, 7F

06/01 19:46, , 8F
收費標準才是最大問題,文末我就說啦
06/01 19:46, 8F

06/01 19:46, , 9F
至少人家判賠多,但給醫師的回報也比較合乎比例.鬼島呢???
06/01 19:46, 9F

06/01 19:47, , 10F
不過法院判賠的數目大多與你收多少錢無關就是
06/01 19:47, 10F

06/01 19:47, , 11F
基本上是考量病患的經濟上損失
06/01 19:47, 11F

06/01 19:48, , 12F
基本上這是不平等契約
06/01 19:48, 12F

06/01 23:03, , 13F
可是我不覺得這個男士有能賺300萬美金的價值耶...
06/01 23:03, 13F

06/01 23:03, , 14F
金額標準在哪,我真的不懂...
06/01 23:03, 14F
該法院該案的連結 http://www.gwinnettcourts.com/home.asp#casedetail/case:10%2dc%2d02212%2ds4/ 網路上看不到影像檔..... 只能從部分新聞中知道他是police officer(警官)

06/02 12:49, , 15F
如果他的對相是歐巴馬就可能
06/02 12:49, 15F

06/02 19:53, , 16F
06/02 19:53, 16F
病方律師還....... Edmond & Lindsay Lawyers get Stunning $5 Million Medical Malpractice Verdict in State Court of Gwinnett County (GA) for Medical Negligence http://www.prweb.com/releases/2012/6/prweb9565188.htm Our firm’s attorneys have over 75 years of combined legal experience; our partners are experienced courtroom advocates; and Roderick Edmond, M.D., J.D., our founding partner, is a licensed medical doctor which gives us a tremendous advantage when handling the medical aspects of all of our cases both in damages and liability. At Edmond & Lindsay, LLP, we strive for excellence every day – and this shows in the battles we have won for our clients. Members of our firm have recovered $772,000,000.00 million for clients over the past 20 years. Therefore, when you feel that you or a loved one has been the victim of medical malpractice; when you feel that you’ve suffered a catastrophic injury because of the carelessness of others; when you feel that a loved one has been injured or died because of the fault of others, this, then, is that time to call Edmond & Lindsay, LLP. This is “When I’m Sorry is not enough.” ※ 編輯: hahawow 來自: 123.192.156.57 (06/02 22:19)
文章代碼(AID): #1Fo9nHNW (medache)
文章代碼(AID): #1Fo9nHNW (medache)