[請益] 本句該使用限定用法還是非限定呢?
1. The country is rich in natural resources which have brought it a great deal
of wealth.
2. The country is rich in natural resources, which have brought it a great deal
of wealth.
請問大家覺得這句話是該用限定(無逗點)還是非限定用法(有逗點)呢?
謝謝
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 223.139.54.38
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1457784951.A.73B.html
→
03/12 22:09, , 1F
03/12 22:09, 1F
→
03/12 22:41, , 2F
03/12 22:41, 2F
原題後面還有一句話
The country is rich in natural resources (which) / (, which ) have brought
it a great deal of wealth. Life is therefore easy for most of the people
who live there.
這題目出的有點奇怪
如果用限定用法(不加逗號)
我們一般會說: 擁有可以/能夠帶來財富的天然資源
但我們會說" 擁有"已經"帶來財富的天然資源 (如句1) 嗎?
又如果用非限定用法(加逗號) (補充敘述)
沒有上文的話，難道不會造成which指(全世界)所有的天然資源嗎?
我在原句想表達的意思是:
這國有(各式各樣的)天然資源。
這些這個國家所擁有的天然資源已經帶給這國家許多財富。
對於住在那裡的大多數人們而言，生活因此很輕鬆。
分開來寫都不是問題。但要用關係代名詞來合成一句話，就不清楚要用句1還句2或是根本不能用關係帶名詞來合成這一句話。
※ 編輯: tucson (223.139.54.38), 03/13/2016 00:28:16
→
03/13 01:42, , 3F
03/13 01:42, 3F
推
03/13 02:46, , 4F
03/13 02:46, 4F
→
03/13 02:49, , 5F
03/13 02:49, 5F
→
03/13 02:49, , 6F
03/13 02:49, 6F
→
03/13 02:50, , 7F
03/13 02:50, 7F
→
03/13 02:51, , 8F
03/13 02:51, 8F
→
03/13 02:52, , 9F
03/13 02:52, 9F
→
03/13 02:52, , 10F
03/13 02:52, 10F
→
03/13 02:52, , 11F
03/13 02:52, 11F
→
03/13 02:52, , 12F
03/13 02:52, 12F
→
03/13 02:53, , 13F
03/13 02:53, 13F
→
03/13 02:53, , 14F
03/13 02:53, 14F
→
03/13 02:55, , 15F
03/13 02:55, 15F
你說選1 但位為何者你寫的大句子是用2(有逗號)的寫法??
→
03/13 02:59, , 16F
03/13 02:59, 16F
→
03/13 03:00, , 17F
03/13 03:00, 17F
推
03/13 11:17, , 18F
03/13 11:17, 18F
※ 編輯: tucson (223.139.54.38), 03/13/2016 20:04:43
→
03/14 05:04, , 19F
03/14 05:04, 19F
→
03/14 05:04, , 20F
03/14 05:04, 20F
Eng-Class 近期熱門文章
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章