[文法] would as soon的句型用法

看板Eng-Class (英文板)作者 (Θ)時間9年前 (2016/06/28 11:22), 9年前編輯推噓3(3015)
留言18則, 2人參與, 最新討論串1/1
請問高手們一個文法觀念 (就算不是高手也歡迎參與討論) http://goo.gl/BsXDik http://goo.gl/X2KC2R http://211.75.39.208/adv/grammar/data/SU591.htm 以上三個網頁我都有看懂了 另外我知道 would rather =would sooner =would just as soon =would as soon =had rather =had sooner =had just as soon =had as soon 我只是想另外請問一個問題: http://211.75.39.208/adv/grammar/data/SU591.htm 這個網頁的最最最下面的句型: would/ had as soon + V1........as V2. 我的認知是這個句型只能有一個主詞 不能像 I would rather you hadn't failed the test. 因為他們有兩個主詞(I 和 you) 另外 would/ had as soon + V1........as V2. 是不是只能講現在或未來的假設 我的認知是好像這個句型不適用「與過去事實相反的假設語氣」 請問我的這兩個認知(單一主詞與時態限制)對嗎? 謝謝高手們!!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.35.105.129 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1467084170.A.82A.html

06/29 01:09, , 1F
這是甚麼文法書? 我每天讀英美文章..從來沒讀過這樣的句子
06/29 01:09, 1F

06/29 02:08, , 2F
原po別篇有附Cambridge的文法說明,http://goo.gl/X2KC2R
06/29 02:08, 2F

06/29 02:24, , 3F
would是modal verb,即使是would as soon的句型,仍脫不了
06/29 02:24, 3F

06/29 02:24, , 4F
『若要表過去時間,要用完成式來表達』的特質啊!所以它一
06/29 02:24, 4F

06/29 02:24, , 5F
樣可以表達過去,即would as soon have + pp
06/29 02:24, 5F
謝謝各位參與討論 ******************* serif大大說的我懂 因為would as soon = would rather 但是我想問的是 would/ had as soon + V1........as V2. 能同一句話有「兩個主詞」嗎? 例如: I would rather you weren't my son. (有兩個主詞) 另外 能表「與過去事實相反的假設語氣」嗎? 我不是只是在說 would as soon 我是說包含兩個 as 的 完整句子 would/ had as soon + V1........as V2. 請知道的人繼續指教 感謝!!! ※ 編輯: aqw123 (114.35.105.129), 06/29/2016 23:23:58

06/30 02:17, , 6F
我Google了一下發現,would as soon +子句 的用例非常少,
06/30 02:17, 6F

06/30 02:17, , 7F
少到現實生活中合理推測大概不會看到母語人士這樣用,所以
06/30 02:17, 7F

06/30 02:18, , 8F
可以暫且接受would as soon只加動詞,不太會加子句;既然
06/30 02:18, 8F

06/30 02:18, , 9F
不加子句,如你所說,整個句子當然只會出現一個主詞。另外
06/30 02:18, 9F

06/30 02:18, , 10F
,關於你說的第二個as,其實不把as V2寫出來的例子還不少哦
06/30 02:18, 10F

06/30 02:18, , 11F
,而且第二個as後面可以加其他詞性的單字,未必有V2。至於
06/30 02:18, 11F

06/30 02:18, , 12F
你問的would as soon能不能用與過去相反的假設,如果你能
06/30 02:18, 12F

06/30 02:18, , 13F
接受我前面說的would as soon後面不加子句而只加動詞原形
06/30 02:18, 13F

06/30 02:18, , 14F
的話,當然就不會有假設語氣了啊。所以我想,我昨天的回覆
06/30 02:18, 14F

06/30 02:18, , 15F
應該已經回答了如何用would as soon表達『寧可之前做...』
06/30 02:18, 15F

06/30 02:18, , 16F
了:
06/30 02:18, 16F

06/30 02:18, , 17F
I'd rather you had done... (我寧願你之前…)
06/30 02:18, 17F

06/30 02:18, , 18F
I'd rather/as soon have done... (我寧願我之前…)
06/30 02:18, 18F
我了解了 感謝!!! ※ 編輯: aqw123 (114.35.105.129), 06/30/2016 10:59:17
文章代碼(AID): #1NSUsAWg (Eng-Class)
文章代碼(AID): #1NSUsAWg (Eng-Class)