[文法] (高手請進)However當連接詞??

看板Eng-Class (英文板)作者 (Θ)時間9年前 (2017/03/06 14:52), 編輯推噓0(008)
留言8則, 2人參與, 最新討論串1/1
請問高手們一個英文文法問題 (就算不是高手也歡迎參與討論) (賀立民老師文法書) http://imgur.com/a/1BMxG 我目前的觀念是 however只是副詞,不當連接詞 (字典中however沒有連接詞的詞性) 因為不是連接詞,所以however不能連接兩個子句 所以一定要用分號(;)來連接兩個句子 however只是當副詞來修飾句子並且轉折語氣 所以我之前一直都認為 I need money, however, I don't want to borrow from him. (上句文法是錯的,however前面要是分號才行) 所以正確的應是 I need money; however, I don't want to borrow from him. (上句文法是對的) 但是賀立民老師說however是副詞連接詞 賀老師把however當成一種連接詞看待 因為盡信書不如無書 所以想跟大家討論一下 請問各位高手們怎麼看 謝謝 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 125.224.236.44 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1488783125.A.656.html

03/06 15:55, , 1F
however=no matter how 另一種用法,即為連接詞功能
03/06 15:55, 1F

03/06 23:25, , 3F
有conj.(注意看例句。不一樣用法/意思)。你說的是adv.的
03/06 23:25, 3F

03/06 23:26, , 4F
部份,下方Usage Note(*1)有提。你之前以為的
03/06 23:26, 4F

03/06 23:26, , 5F
" ... , however, ..."算是有爭議的用法。日常上(特別是
03/06 23:26, 5F

03/06 23:27, , 6F
informal styles/usage)很常見。要應付考試的話(GMAT這類
03/06 23:27, 6F

03/06 23:27, , 7F
)這種有爭議用法通常不是答案
03/06 23:27, 7F

03/06 23:27, , 8F
(*1) · When however is used to join clauses ...
03/06 23:27, 8F
文章代碼(AID): #1OlGSLPM (Eng-Class)
文章代碼(AID): #1OlGSLPM (Eng-Class)