[問題] 問一題閱讀

看板GRE (GRE入學考試)作者 (@@)時間14年前 (2012/05/16 08:56), 編輯推噓4(407)
留言11則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
Since 1953, many experimental attempts to synthesize the chemical constituents of life under “primitive Earth conditions” have been performed, but none of these experiments has produced anything approaching the complexity of the simplest organism. They have demonstrated, however, that a variety of the complex molecules currently making up living organisms could have been present in the early ocean and atmosphere, with only one limitation: such molecules are synthesized far less readily when oxygen-containing compounds dominate the atmosphere. Therefore some scientists postulate that the Earth’s earliest atmosphere, unlike that of today, was dominated by hydrogen, methane, and ammonia.   From these studies, scientists have concluded that the surface of the primitive Earth was covered with oceans containing the molecules fundamental to life. Although, at present, scientists cannot explain how these relatively small molecules combined to produce larger, more complex molecules, some scientists have precipitously ventured hypotheses that attempt to explain the development, from lager molecules, of the earliest self-duplicating organisms. ============================================================================== Q:The primary purpose of the passage is to   (A) point out that theories about how life developed on Earth have changed little since 1953   (B) warn of increasing levels of hydrogen, methane, and ammonia in the Earth’s atmosphere   (C) describe the development since 1953 of some scientists’ understanding of how life began on Earth   (D) demonstrate that the synthesis of life in the laboratory is too difficult for modern technology   (E) describe how primitive atmospheric conditions produced the complex molecules of living organisms ============================================================================== 正解為C,但我想請問為什麼D是錯的?? 小弟先謝過各位了 ^^" -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 111.251.224.140

05/16 21:16, , 1F
可以問一下這題是從哪裡看到的嗎?
05/16 21:16, 1F

05/16 21:17, , 2F
D錯的原因我覺得是因為他整篇並沒有要在證明什麼,而
05/16 21:17, 2F

05/16 23:07, , 3F
是GRE的考古題~
05/16 23:07, 3F

05/16 23:08, , 4F
說錯 是真題 不知道是不是"考古題"
05/16 23:08, 4F

05/17 00:52, , 5F
你可以先說說看為什麼D是對的!
05/17 00:52, 5F

05/17 14:40, , 6F
文中不是說none of these exp. has produced...了嗎?
05/17 14:40, 6F

05/18 23:18, , 7F
文中沒有提到任何moden technology,只是表述一個
05/18 23:18, 7F

05/18 23:19, , 8F
argument從開始到後來的變化
05/18 23:19, 8F

05/18 23:25, , 9F
是modern抱歉,我的淺見,我也想了很久
05/18 23:25, 9F

05/21 09:41, , 10F
從生物的觀點解題,只有講到研究organisms=有機體
05/21 09:41, 10F

05/21 09:45, , 11F
研究內容沒有提到以現階段是否可製造到life=生命體
05/21 09:45, 11F
文章代碼(AID): #1FiliZ0A (GRE)
文章代碼(AID): #1FiliZ0A (GRE)