[問題] 閱讀理解36 #21 Q7

看板GRE (GRE入學考試)作者 (ㄚ不拉)時間13年前 (2012/11/15 21:46), 編輯推噓8(8017)
留言25則, 7人參與, 最新討論串1/1
7.On turning 65 years old, everyone living in the town of Malton becomes eligible to receive a card that guarantees discounts on most goods and services sold in the town. Census records for 1990 show that 2, 450 inhabitants of Malton turned 64 in that year. Yet . in 1991 over 3,000 people applied for and properly received discount cards. So clearly some of Malton's population growth between 1990 and 1992 must be attributable to migration into the city by people in their mid -60's Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends? (A) The town of Malton has no complete census records for 1991. (B) The overall size of the population of Malton grew by over 500 during 1990. (C) Fewer people applied for and received discount cards in 1991 than did so in 1992. (D) Among the people 65 years old or older who moved into Malton in 1991. there was no one who did not apply for a discount card . (E) In general. people who applied for and received discount cards in 1991 first became eligible to do so in that year 解答給的是D 但我怎麼看都覺得是E 不知道有沒有大大有寫過這題 提出你們的想法~ -- 動機........才是王道 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.114.214.80

11/15 21:56, , 1F
assumption考的是 缺少哪個條件則文中結論不成立
11/15 21:56, 1F

11/15 21:57, , 2F
題目的結論是 因為很多突然暴增很多申請者 推測是
11/15 21:57, 2F

11/15 21:57, , 3F
突然移入 所以選D 如果移入的人都沒有去申請
11/15 21:57, 3F

11/15 21:57, , 4F
則原文結論不成立
11/15 21:57, 4F

11/15 22:06, , 5F
D不是說 每個符合資格的人都去申請嗎
11/15 22:06, 5F

11/15 23:22, , 6F
(E)錯在它無法加強文章的推論(Assumption有點類似選
11/15 23:22, 6F

11/15 23:23, , 7F
support~(D)有加強所以是它
11/15 23:23, 7F

11/15 23:57, , 8F
就是每個新移入且合資格人的都去申請 所以人數才會
11/15 23:57, 8F

11/15 23:58, , 9F
暴增
11/15 23:58, 9F

11/16 00:00, , 10F
D是說每個>=65歲的「新移入者」,每個人都有去申請
11/16 00:00, 10F

11/16 00:24, , 11F
E和移民者無關,可以不用考慮吧
11/16 00:24, 11F

11/16 13:15, , 12F
因為其他答案更差吧
11/16 13:15, 12F

11/17 19:15, , 13F
謝謝各位的回答~
11/17 19:15, 13F

11/20 17:20, , 14F
我也覺得答案應該是E
11/20 17:20, 14F

11/20 17:21, , 15F
若非D,則可以說移入者並非每個人都去申請
11/20 17:21, 15F

11/20 17:22, , 16F
但文中並未提及移入人口,所以無法判斷是否少了幾個
11/20 17:22, 16F

11/20 17:22, , 17F
就無法達到3000人
11/20 17:22, 17F

11/20 17:25, , 18F
或是說即使有了D這個條件,你也無法確定多的就是
11/20 17:25, 18F

11/20 17:25, , 19F
因為移入人口造成的
11/20 17:25, 19F

11/20 17:27, , 20F
但是若選E則可以確定Malton市最多就2450人可以在
11/20 17:27, 20F

11/20 17:28, , 21F
1991年得到卡,則至少550一定是移入人口造成的
11/20 17:28, 21F

11/20 17:34, , 22F
個人看法@@ 煩請高手指教
11/20 17:34, 22F

11/20 23:10, , 23F
補充:應考慮超過65歲卻未在滿65歲當年就申請的原居民
11/20 23:10, 23F

09/06 11:04, , 24F
我也覺得怎麼看都是E,原因跟樓上一樣
09/06 11:04, 24F

09/06 11:06, , 25F
如果那年湧進2000個老人,可以不滿足D也成立
09/06 11:06, 25F
文章代碼(AID): #1GfF9GrZ (GRE)
文章代碼(AID): #1GfF9GrZ (GRE)