[問題] PMP 情境題

看板P_Management (專案/產品管理)作者 (莎拉夫人)時間16年前 (2009/05/06 20:04), 編輯推噓14(14014)
留言28則, 10人參與, 最新討論串1/1
今天做題目 有個問題讓我想不出答案..... Managemant has provided you with a project charter, and you are in the process of creating a project scope statement. You have asked the team for input to ensure that the project scope statement is complete. However, the team is struggling woth defining the scope. Which of the following BEST describes the problem ? A. A WBS was not completed before the project scope statement was begun. B. The team is working on the project scope statement without the benefit of organizational process assets. C. The team is in the scope definition process and needs the project scope statement as an input. D. The project objectives were not identified before the project scope statement was begun. 版上有人可以協助解惑和指導嗎? 謝謝~~~~~ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 123.194.165.130

05/06 23:55, , 1F
是 D嗎 :P
05/06 23:55, 1F

05/07 17:31, , 2F
我認為是C
05/07 17:31, 2F

05/07 17:31, , 3F
有中文嗎?可能更方便了解關鍵語意
05/07 17:31, 3F

05/07 19:59, , 4F
C+, 專案章程應該已經清楚描述發起人的目標
05/07 19:59, 4F

05/07 22:47, , 5F
我選C
05/07 22:47, 5F

05/07 22:56, , 6F
選C的話有點弔詭的地方是,專案範圍說明書是範圍定義的output
05/07 22:56, 6F

05/07 22:58, , 7F
但如果要解釋成初步範圍說明書的話,則答案是C沒錯
05/07 22:58, 7F

05/07 22:58, , 8F
所以如果是我的話,我會選擇D囉,可以再討論看看
05/07 22:58, 8F

05/07 23:30, , 9F
I would choice "D" :-)
05/07 23:30, 9F

05/08 00:32, , 10F
也許C不一定對,選D的理由是?專案目標不是已經在章程中?
05/08 00:32, 10F

05/08 10:26, , 11F
B,根據ITTO, project scope statement的四個input中,
05/08 10:26, 11F

05/08 10:26, , 12F
其中一個是organizational process assets
05/08 10:26, 12F

05/08 10:27, , 13F
(組織過程資產)
05/08 10:27, 13F

05/08 10:30, , 14F
C不對,根據題目,project scope statement是output
05/08 10:30, 14F

05/08 10:32, , 15F
D不對,project objectives已經在charter中了
05/08 10:32, 15F

05/08 10:33, , 16F
A就不用說了,製作WBS還太早
05/08 10:33, 16F

05/08 10:35, , 17F
這題只是單純考你ITTO而已,別想得太複雜
05/08 10:35, 17F

05/08 12:53, , 18F
同意B是合理答案,難怪覺得C像是又不像答案 XD
05/08 12:53, 18F

05/08 13:20, , 19F
這麼說來 FROM ABASE001 B 比較合理
05/08 13:20, 19F

05/08 13:20, , 20F
想想 挺對的
05/08 13:20, 20F

05/08 13:21, , 21F
你都已經知道了 目標(object) 但遲遲無法確定範圍的原因
05/08 13:21, 21F

05/08 13:22, , 22F
有可能是不知道公司有多少資源 可用
05/08 13:22, 22F

05/08 13:23, , 23F
BTW 有誰可以告訴我 組織過程資產在現實中是指什麼
05/08 13:23, 23F

05/10 19:50, , 24F
LL
05/10 19:50, 24F

05/10 23:46, , 25F
LL是其中一部份 組織過程資產是指所有相關的資訊或文字
05/10 23:46, 25F

05/10 23:47, , 26F
或任何紀錄 例如專案成員的合照或技術執照培訓等
05/10 23:47, 26F

05/11 00:57, , 27F
B+1
05/11 00:57, 27F

05/11 10:21, , 28F
謝謝大家幫忙詳解,這題答案是B
05/11 10:21, 28F
文章代碼(AID): #1A0NpOCC (P_Management)
文章代碼(AID): #1A0NpOCC (P_Management)