[問題] Decision letter沒說是大或小修

看板PhD (博士班)作者CR950111 (ccrrss)時間1年前 (2023/09/15 13:32)推噓2(2推 0噓 20→)

留言22則, 4人參與討論串1/1

各位前輩好目前手上有個研究投SSCI (Wiley出版社) 系統沒辦法看到with editor/under review等資訊 Submit/Resubmit後只會看到 "This submission is under consideration and cannot be edited." 從R1~R3 主編的decision letters 只提到要修改但沒有寫明是major/minor revision 例如主編要求R1的decision letter "I encourage you to respond to the reviewers' comments and revise your paper accordingly. Once completed, I will reevaluate the revised version and decide on next steps as we move toward publication." R2 "Your paper continues to show promise, and I would like to encourage you to undertake some additional revisions in order to move the work forward toward publication" R3 "they have a smaller group of targeted concerns that need to be addressed before the work can move forward to publication" 因為投稿經驗不多之前投的Springer出版社是的SSCI期刊用EditorialManager 至少能看到狀態以及major/minor 是否有前輩有遇過這風格的主編? 會不會直接寄信問主編這到底是major還是minor呢XD? Wiley新投稿系統是否都無法看明確的狀態? 老闆看到R3的decision letter覺得應該是小修比較大的機會主編看完就會做決定了不過過了十幾天沒什麼消息真是難熬這次投稿進到R3 修改後提交到現在等待的頗焦慮(明白這是投稿必經之路) 另外頗有趣的是R3的decision letter多了一段R1 R2沒有的文字 "This journal offers a number of license options for published papers; information about this is available here: https://xxx.xxx.xxx " 網站主要是宣告些出版的版權協議相關的內容、OA等資訊等待中安慰自己是否離accpeted又近了一點... -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 180.217.229.243 (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/PhD/M.1694755964.A.2D4.html

→

YoursEver

09/15 13:46, 1年前 , 1^F

09/15 13:46, 1^F

→

YoursEver

09/15 13:46, 1年前 , 2^F

09/15 13:46, 2^F

→

saltlake

09/15 16:53, 1年前 , 3^F

09/15 16:53, 3^F