[請益] 句子汰換的問題~

看板TOEFL_iBT (TOEFL_iBT托福)作者 (gemini)時間13年前 (2012/08/19 15:00), 編輯推噓2(2012)
留言14則, 5人參與, 最新討論串1/1
最近做到了一個題目,想請各位高手幫我解惑一下~ Observations have found that the black hole at the center of this galaxy M81, which is believed to be 70 million times more massive than the sun, generates energy and radiation as it pull gas inwards at a high speed. (A) Watchers have discovered a black hole at the center of the galaxy, believed to be bigger than the sun, which generate radiation as it eats (B) Scientists have identified a black hole at the center of a galaxy; they believe it is much more massive than the sun, which creates energy as it pull its food in very quickly. (C) There has been a discovery of a massive black hole in Milky Way, which is huge, and this black hole eats a lot. (D) A huge black hole at the center of a galaxy is belived to be 70 million times larger than the sun; it generates energy as it pulls in gas in gas at a high speed. 我的想法是這樣 Observations have found that the black hole at the center of this galaxy M81, which(代替this galaxy M81) is believed to be 70 million times more massive than the sun,(共用前面the black hole的主詞) generates energy and radiation as it pull gas inwards at a high speed. 觀察家們發現了一個黑洞位於一個質量比太陽還大了 70 million倍的銀河系M81的中央, 而當這黑洞以很快的速度拉進氣體時會產生能量和輻射 (A)Watchers have discovered a black hole at the center of the galaxy, believed to be bigger than the sun, (which generate radiation as it eats) 產生輻射的是黑洞不是太陽 (B) Scientists have identified a black hole at the center of a galaxy; they believe (it is much more massive than the sun), which creates energy as it pull its food in very quickly. 我覺得這邊的it是black hole所以也錯, 因為原句是說galaxy跟sun比較 (C) There has been a discovery of a massive black hole in Milky Way, which is huge, and this (black hole eats a lot.) 原句也沒有說吃很多 (D) A huge black hole at the center of a galaxy (is belived to be 70 million times larger than the sun); it generates energy as it pulls in gas in gas at a high speed. 跟B好像,但本文是說galaxy跟sun比較,所以也錯 這樣不是都沒有答案了QQ 不過給的答案是B 想著想著一個早上就過了!!不過還是想不通... 還是我本文理解錯誤!!?? 如果本文的which是指black hole就解了 可是which不是就是補述前面的名詞this galaxy? 希望各位強者能幫幫我打通任督二脈! Thx! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.37.130.6

08/19 15:16, , 1F
which是黑洞...
08/19 15:16, 1F

08/19 15:19, , 2F
!!!???為什麼不是galaxy
08/19 15:19, 2F

08/19 16:08, , 3F
這題我的看法與代詞無關請參考...
08/19 16:08, 3F

08/19 16:11, , 4F
A:70 millions times..與 bigger than語意差太多
08/19 16:11, 4F

08/19 16:13, , 5F
B就算對也是超級鳥的答案 B裡的which指的是sun
08/19 16:13, 5F

08/19 16:14, , 6F
C:原句說70 millions times 但沒說代表巨大且同您所
08/19 16:14, 6F

08/19 16:16, , 7F
舉的例子同..D也是相同問題 故B最適切
08/19 16:16, 7F

08/19 16:18, , 8F
我認為D比較符合該題答案
08/19 16:18, 8F
謝謝以上的說明~ 其實我一開始也選D耶,因為我覺得B說sun generate radiation根本文無關 那如果先不管選項 單看本文的which which可以代替的到底是直接前面的名詞還是在更前面的主詞!!?? 這有點困擾我@@ 感恩~ ※ 編輯: watermirour 來自: 114.37.130.6 (08/19 16:32)

08/19 22:43, , 9F
這句原文是:觀測數據發現位於M81銀河系的黑洞,相信其
08/19 22:43, 9F

08/19 22:45, , 10F
質量是太陽得70 millions倍之多....
08/19 22:45, 10F

08/19 22:47, , 11F
另外您所提的which,請注意他前面都有逗號,也就是說它
08/19 22:47, 11F

08/19 22:50, , 12F
不是指代其前面的名詞,而是對前一句的補充說明
08/19 22:50, 12F

08/20 21:30, , 13F
我覺直覺會選(B),因為massive應該是指質量
08/20 21:30, 13F

08/20 21:30, , 14F
所以(A)(D)big,large都失真了
08/20 21:30, 14F
文章代碼(AID): #1GC8xolP (TOEFL_iBT)
文章代碼(AID): #1GC8xolP (TOEFL_iBT)