[Mind] Memory

看板EngTalk (全英文聊天)作者 (我的英文還是太爛)時間19年前 (2005/04/13 23:39), 編輯推噓5(5017)
留言22則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/1
Memory is a magic word. You can sense it, but you can't feel it. It's in your mind, but you are not sure if it is true or something made up. Have you ever thought about your memories were all fictitious stories someone told you to deceive you? I did, but I was not sure if I was right. Maybe I just over- reacted to this lexicon and its extended meanings, but a game I played few weeks ago reminded me of the intriguing subject. The game is called Final Fantacy VII. I believe some of you might have played it before. The storyline is perfect and plots abundant. Back then the protagonist Cloud was a kid, weird and aloof. He liked a girl at his age named Tifa, but somehow he couldn't catch her attention because she had her circle of friends. Being excluded from the circle, Cloud felt dejected and useless, until one day he believed if he could join the SOILDER, the most powerful military organization in that world, he could be strong and have everyone's eyes on him. The news spreaded fast and Tifa noticed him at last, expecting him to come back with the highest rank in SOILDER. However, Cloud didn't make himself even noticed in SOILDER, but returned to his village asserting his fake identity of SOILDER that he couldn't achieve. As the story go on, Cloud had been blended into the memory he made up himself, and believed he was of the highest rank of SOILDER without any doubt. His identity lasted for a while until his colleage appeared and gave signs of his past. Cloud started to doubt his realness, worrying if he did not exist in the past, what else did? His sanity finally fell apart and he could not piece each of them back to normal. In other words, he was lost in his split ego. Of course the story doesn't end here and I can tell you Tifa save him in the rest part of the story. This image refrains in the movie Butterfly Effect I saw several months ago. The movie is about a man, who suffers from slight amnesia, finding himself able to recover his lost part of memory by reading his diary recording his lost part, and then change his future (or presence). The point is if he can recreate his memory, will the word memory mean anything? From both FF VII and Butterfly Effect, I find memory untrustworthy and unreliable, in particular with the part when you can hardly remember, but people tell you that did exist. Can there be the possibility that people create the memory for you, or twist, distort, disfigure so you fill the blank of your memory with everything people say, so you can assure yourself with true existence of yourself? I don't know, but I do know when memory is created by at least two people, the lost part can be refilled by another person. However, who can you really trust? Do those memories really exist? -- I don't know if I made it too long or put them in an understandable way, but I will appreciate any share of their feelings about this. :) -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 218.172.187.69

140.113.192.6 04/14, , 1F
Your view-point is really interesting!!
140.113.192.6 04/14, 1F

140.113.192.6 04/14, , 2F
As I have learned in Psychology class,
140.113.192.6 04/14, 2F

140.113.192.6 04/14, , 3F
it's possible to create memory that doesn't exist
140.113.192.6 04/14, 3F

218.166.90.91 04/14, , 4F
good article!
218.166.90.91 04/14, 4F

140.117.43.92 04/14, , 5F
wmn, I can see your point, but what if someone
140.117.43.92 04/14, 5F

140.117.43.92 04/14, , 6F
prove your memory is wrong? For example, when
140.117.43.92 04/14, 6F

140.117.43.92 04/14, , 7F
someone's memory is different from yours, but
140.117.43.92 04/14, 7F

140.117.43.92 04/14, , 8F
u can remember u two did that thing togeter.
140.117.43.92 04/14, 8F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 9F
Is it possible that you two perceive the same
140.113.192.6 04/17, 9F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 10F
thing differently?
140.113.192.6 04/17, 10F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 11F
Sometimes,I am not confident that I did something
140.113.192.6 04/17, 11F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 12F
although I know I have really done it.
140.113.192.6 04/17, 12F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 13F
Since I can obtain the same kind of feelings and
140.113.192.6 04/17, 13F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 14F
experience in my dream, how can I know that
140.113.192.6 04/17, 14F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 15F
what I have done is real, not in my dream?
140.113.192.6 04/17, 15F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 16F
The point is that when I am recalling my memories
140.113.192.6 04/17, 16F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 17F
I am not sure whether the realism comes from my
140.113.192.6 04/17, 17F

140.113.192.6 04/17, , 18F
experience in my real life or in my dream
140.113.192.6 04/17, 18F

218.172.181.165 04/19, , 19F
i can agree with u, and i am fasicinated with
218.172.181.165 04/19, 19F

218.172.181.165 04/19, , 20F
the idea of dreams, that u mentioned to prove
218.172.181.165 04/19, 20F

218.172.181.165 04/19, , 21F
if we live in a dream or reality, that's the
218.172.181.165 04/19, 21F

218.172.181.165 04/19, , 22F
counterpart of what I've been thinking :)
218.172.181.165 04/19, 22F
※ 編輯: hamper 來自: 218.172.181.165 (04/19 13:25)
文章代碼(AID): #12NJqqNU (EngTalk)
文章代碼(AID): #12NJqqNU (EngTalk)