[語文] OG-10-SC88

看板GMAT (GMAT入學考試)作者 (人生需要不斷冒險)時間16年前 (2009/11/20 19:30), 編輯推噓5(5023)
留言28則, 6人參與, 7年前最新討論串1/1
88. The Emperor Augustus, it appears, commissioned an idealized sculpture portrait, the features of which are so unrealistic as to constitute what one scholar calls an "artificial face." (A) so unrealistic as to constitute (B) so unrealistic they constituted (C) so unrealistic that they have constituted (D) unrealistic enough so that they constitute (E) unrealistic enough so as to constitute OG解釋The verbs are and calls indicate that the sculpture is being viewed and judged in the present. Thus, neither the past tense verb constituted (in B) nor the present perfect verb have constituted (in C) is correct; both suggest that the statue's features once constituted an artificial face but no longer do so. 現在完成式也有表過去到"現在"的狀態 可以請教一下為何OG這樣解釋嗎? 用 have +pp 就表示no longer do so? -- Que Pasa -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 203.73.249.13

11/20 20:10, , 1F
現在完成式好像是強調過去到現在 所以暗指了未來
11/20 20:10, 1F

11/20 20:10, , 2F
"未必"會持續如此 不知道是這樣說嗎@__@a...
11/20 20:10, 2F

11/21 16:53, , 3F
樓上說的好! 另外現在完成式也有近期之內已完成的意
11/21 16:53, 3F

11/21 16:53, , 4F
思在
11/21 16:53, 4F

11/21 23:44, , 5F
現在完成式,動作完成沒,是不一定的。書上不都這麼
11/21 23:44, 5F

11/21 23:53, , 6F
說?
11/21 23:53, 6F

11/22 00:05, , 7F
這題的時態問題,根據語意,應該指的是「客觀事實」或
11/22 00:05, 7F

11/22 00:06, , 8F
「通則」之意,所以用過去式或現在完成式,並不合適。
11/22 00:06, 8F

11/22 00:07, , 9F
至於現在完成式,一定包含了過去到現在,這無庸置疑。
11/22 00:07, 9F

11/22 00:15, , 10F
感謝P大再度點了我另一個看法.精確!
11/22 00:15, 10F

11/22 00:34, , 11F
最討厭時態的問題了,實戰的時候句意都看不懂了,根本無
11/22 00:34, 11F

11/22 00:35, , 12F
法判斷用什麼時態才正確...T_T....這題用so...as to及
11/22 00:35, 12F

11/22 00:36, , 13F
so...that的慣用法排除 BDE, 然後AC比較短選A....XD
11/22 00:36, 13F

11/22 00:37, , 14F
或者直接5個比較長短,雖然AB看起來差不多長,但視覺上來
11/22 00:37, 14F

11/22 00:37, , 15F
看,A短一些些 <-----(我是亂講的 XD)
11/22 00:37, 15F

11/22 00:38, , 16F
AC可以比較長短,是有根據的,so...as to跟so...that同時
11/22 00:38, 16F

11/22 00:39, , 17F
出現的時候,可以注意一下前面發動作的主詞,還有that後
11/22 00:39, 17F

11/22 00:39, , 18F
面接的主詞,如果是相同的話(以這題來講,they指代前面
11/22 00:39, 18F

11/22 00:40, , 19F
的features),這樣的情況下,寫兩次相同的主詞,不如直
11/22 00:40, 19F

11/22 00:40, , 20F
接用so...as to來的簡潔
11/22 00:40, 20F

11/22 00:41, , 21F
莫神說:簡潔是最高指導原則!
11/22 00:41, 21F

11/22 00:42, , 22F
不過我文法不好,單字量不大才這樣搞啦,好孩子還是應該
11/22 00:42, 22F

11/22 00:42, , 23F
多學習正確的時態用法
11/22 00:42, 23F

11/22 00:50, , 24F
謝謝 W大.我有去翻找了一些so...as to&so..that的例句.
11/22 00:50, 24F

11/22 00:51, , 25F
是要看主詞是否造成岐義來判斷.OG12*171提是一例.謝謝
11/22 00:51, 25F

11/22 00:51, , 26F
你說不定會找到例外的,我承認這不是最好用的技巧
11/22 00:51, 26F

11/22 00:51, , 27F
但我在這題裡面只能這樣解了 XD
11/22 00:51, 27F

12/02 18:44, 7年前 , 28F
這題的時態問題,根據語 https://noxiv.com
12/02 18:44, 28F
文章代碼(AID): #1B1dtkNW (GMAT)
文章代碼(AID): #1B1dtkNW (GMAT)