[SC. ] OG12-70

看板GMAT (GMAT入學考試)作者 (永遠都有新希望...llb)時間15年前 (2010/09/23 14:29), 編輯推噓2(2018)
留言20則, 3人參與, 7年前最新討論串1/1
70. His studies of ice-polished rocks in his Alpine homeland, far outside the range of present-day glaciers, led Louis Agassiz in 1837 to propose the concept of an age in which great ice sheets had existed in now currently temperate areas. (A) in which great ice sheets had existed in now currently temperate areas (B) in which great ice sheets existed in what are now temperate areas (C) when great ice sheets existed where there were areas now temperate (D) when great ice sheets had existed in current temperate areas (E) when great ice sheets existed in areas now that are temperate 我想請問時態的問題, OG上面說ice sheets existed要用過去式,不用過去完成式 我看了CD上的解釋,都說因為沒有明顯時間順序上的比較,所以要用過去式, 但能否解釋為ice sheets存在於Louis Agassiz提出concept之前 所以是發生在過去的過去,使用過去完成式呢? 感謝!!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.131.139.7

09/23 23:24, , 1F
B和D應該是比較出來的,因為SC不是選最對的,而是選最
09/23 23:24, 1F

09/23 23:25, , 2F
適當最優美的。
09/23 23:25, 2F

09/23 23:25, , 3F
in which比起when更有指定"那個時代"的意味
09/23 23:25, 3F

09/23 23:26, , 4F
且如果用when,把它還原後變成:great ice sheets exist
09/23 23:26, 4F

09/23 23:27, , 5F
are now temperate areas "an age"(=when)←怪怪的
09/23 23:27, 5F

09/23 23:28, , 6F
用in which,great ice....existed...areas "in an age"
09/23 23:28, 6F

09/23 23:29, , 7F
這不是漂亮多了~^^
09/23 23:29, 7F

09/23 23:31, , 8F
另外,他還想強調冰河"所存在的地方是現代的溫帶"
09/23 23:31, 8F

09/23 23:32, , 9F
如果是D,就只說冰河"存在過現在的溫帶"失去了原題想強
09/23 23:32, 9F

09/23 23:32, , 10F
調的FU~
09/23 23:32, 10F

09/23 23:33, , 11F
套句補習班老師的話"介係詞+關代"多多多多選XD
09/23 23:33, 11F

09/23 23:38, , 12F
不過OG裡面是說when和in which都可以指稱 an age
09/23 23:38, 12F

09/23 23:41, , 13F
似乎GMAC在過去式和過去完成式之間偏好過去式的答案...
09/23 23:41, 13F

09/23 23:49, , 14F
但是 如果是這樣記憶 考試的時候 一緊張一定直奔D...
09/23 23:49, 14F

09/23 23:50, , 15F
但是 如果從介係詞關代的倒裝概念出發 往往都是正解
09/23 23:50, 15F

09/23 23:52, , 16F
就好像你提出來的"為何不能說成是在學說出現前發生的呢?
09/23 23:52, 16F

09/23 23:52, , 17F
這樣一來 以後只要類似的題型出現 非常容易搞混
09/23 23:52, 17F

09/23 23:53, , 18F
本來該選過去完成式的 沒選到(因為只記了過去>過去完成)
09/23 23:53, 18F

09/24 17:03, , 19F
但我很怕記得介係詞關代之後又出現例外...
09/24 17:03, 19F

12/02 18:53, 7年前 , 20F
用in which,g https://noxiv.com
12/02 18:53, 20F
文章代碼(AID): #1CclEzQa (GMAT)
文章代碼(AID): #1CclEzQa (GMAT)