[SC. ] GWD-23-Q20

看板GMAT (GMAT入學考試)作者 (good!)時間15年前 (2010/10/22 22:20), 編輯推噓12(1209)
留言21則, 6人參與, 7年前最新討論串1/1
2. GWD-23-Q23 After several years of rapid growth, the healthy care company became one of the largest health care providers in the metropolitan area, while it then proved unable to handle the increase in business, falling months behind in its payment to doctors and hospitals. (A)while it then proved unable to handle the increase in business, falling months behind in its payment to (B)while it then proved unable to handle the increase in business and fell months behind in its payment to (C)but then it proved unable to handle the increase in business, falling months behind in its paying (D)but then proving unable to handle the increase in business, falling months behind in paying (E)but then proved unable to handle the increase in business, falling months behind in paying 正確答案是E 我選A 想請問一下版大 就我的認知及曼哈頓語法說 除非有插入句 逗點後面的,BUT 應該要是獨立子句才對 為什麼E後面沒有主詞會對呢?? 請各版大指教 謝謝!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 125.227.130.95

10/22 22:51, , 1F
我的想法是while沒有辦法表現出轉折的意思,所以AB可以先刪
10/22 22:51, 1F

10/22 22:52, , 2F
另外是proved在這句中是過去分詞,而不是過去式動詞,如果有it
10/22 22:52, 2F

10/22 22:52, , 3F
就反而變成沒有be動詞,所以選擇E,視為將主詞及be動詞省略
10/22 22:52, 3F

10/22 22:54, , 4F
D省略的原因是"被證明"應該要選擇proved,而非proving
10/22 22:54, 4F

10/22 23:24, , 5F
所以說這裡的but不作對等連接詞用嗎??
10/22 23:24, 5F

10/22 23:45, , 6F
我覺得這篇中but仍然是對等連接詞,只是主詞和動詞省略
10/22 23:45, 6F

10/22 23:46, , 7F
也就是說: ...but then (the...company was) proved...
10/22 23:46, 7F

10/23 00:02, , 8F
是喔,因為我不知道對等連接詞可以刪掉主詞和動詞的用法
10/23 00:02, 8F

10/23 00:02, , 9F
我再回去看看文法書好了 謝謝J大!!y
10/23 00:02, 9F

10/23 01:15, , 10F
如果我看到可以刪而沒刪 我就會覺得red 默默劃叉
10/23 01:15, 10F

10/23 01:16, , 11F
除非因為時態不同而存在
10/23 01:16, 11F

10/23 01:22, , 12F
while有對比的意思 但while it then...then不能這樣用吧
10/23 01:22, 12F

10/23 08:56, , 13F
數學換密碼了 mengxiang
10/23 08:56, 13F

10/24 01:09, , 14F
proved 是主動式 與became 平行 不是被動喔
10/24 01:09, 14F

10/24 01:11, , 15F
company應該沒辦法主動prove unable吧...
10/24 01:11, 15F

10/24 01:21, , 16F
我之前也這樣以為 不過參考pp2-105題也是類似的用法
10/24 01:21, 16F

10/24 01:25, , 17F
prove 是用主動表被動語態
10/24 01:25, 17F

10/24 01:27, , 18F
喔喔~感謝!多學到了!所以這題考的應該是主詞提出後but的平衡
10/24 01:27, 18F

10/24 01:31, , 19F
但這樣的話C錯的原因是因為比E更不簡潔嗎?
10/24 01:31, 19F

10/24 03:16, , 20F
我覺得E清晰,且C-in its paying(wrong form要改payment)
10/24 03:16, 20F

12/02 18:53, 7年前 , 21F
我覺得E清晰,且C-i https://noxiv.com
12/02 18:53, 21F
文章代碼(AID): #1CmPsf92 (GMAT)
文章代碼(AID): #1CmPsf92 (GMAT)