PTT職涯區 / GMAT (GMAT入學考試)

[SC. ] 新PP

看板GMAT (GMAT入學考試)作者 (氣球雲)時間15年前 (2011/06/28 19:55), 編輯推噓6(6推 0噓 42→)
留言48則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/1
104. (29915-!-item-!-188;#058&004465) The yield per acre of coffee berries varies enormously in that a single tree, depending on both its size and on climate and altitude, could produce enough berries to make between one and twelve pounds of dried beans a year. (A) enormously in that a single tree, depending on both its size and on climate and altitude, could produce (B) enormously in that a single tree, dependent on its size and also on climate and altitude, is able to produce (C) enormously, because a single tree, depending on its size and on climate and altitude, is able to produce (D) enormously, because a single tree, being dependent on its size, climate, and altitude, is capable of producing (E) enormously, because a single tree, dependent both on its size as well as on climate and altitude, could produce 答案是C 請問 B 錯是因為also 嗎? 105. (29961-!-item-!-188;#058&004575) 2001 proved to be the automaker's first losing year since 1992, when the company had lost $7.4 billion, which was primarily because of almost $7 billion in accounting charges. (A) when the company had lost $7.4 billion, which was primarily because of (B) when the company had lost $7.4 billion, primarily resulting from (C) when the company lost $7.4 billion, primarily because of (D) which is when the company lost $7.4 billion, and that was primarily because of (E) which is when the company lost $7.4 billion, primarily resulting from 答案是C 想問題意!! 很多解釋都是說 when 是1992 但我覺得是2001 那大家覺得呢???? 謝謝 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 111.249.75.127
推
06/28 20:16, , 1F
B錯是因為dependent. and also不是排錯點
06/28 20:16, 1F
→
06/28 20:17, , 2F
when是修飾1992
06/28 20:17, 2F
→
06/28 21:12, , 3F
可是很多人都說 dependind 跟depent都可以用!!
06/28 21:12, 3F
→
06/28 21:13, , 4F
所以那不是 錯因!
06/28 21:13, 4F
→
06/28 21:13, , 5F
修飾1992不就變成那一年虧損 可是前面那句不是說
06/28 21:13, 5F
→
06/28 21:13, , 6F
2001年是第一年虧損嗎?
06/28 21:13, 6F
推
06/28 22:42, , 7F
第一件事：很多人說都可以，不表示它是對的。
06/28 22:42, 7F
→
06/28 22:42, , 8F
depent是形容詞，只能修飾tree，這樣句意不合邏輯。
06/28 22:42, 8F
→
06/28 22:44, , 9F
depending分詞，它是可以形容前面的動作或是行為。
06/28 22:44, 9F
→
06/28 22:46, , 10F
B與正解的差異點就是depent, in that, and also。
06/28 22:46, 10F
→
06/28 22:46, , 11F
and also我百分之百確定它不是排錯點，因為它有出現在
06/28 22:46, 11F
→
06/28 22:46, , 12F
正確選項中過>
06/28 22:46, 12F
→
06/28 22:47, , 13F
至於in that與because 這個很難解釋，他們差異非常細微
06/28 22:47, 13F
→
06/28 22:49, , 14F
所以，我很少用這個來排錯，不過表因果還是偏好because
06/28 22:49, 14F
→
06/28 22:55, , 15F
comma + wh-在正常狀況下，都是修飾離它最近的名詞
06/28 22:55, 15F
→
06/28 22:57, , 16F
是“自從1992年來”的第一次虧損，不是所有歷史中的
06/28 22:57, 16F
→
06/28 22:57, , 17F
的第一次虧損。
06/28 22:57, 17F
→
06/28 23:00, , 18F
如果照你的解釋，when就應該放在句首,它放在1992年後面
06/28 23:00, 18F
→
06/28 23:01, , 19F
很容易引起ambiguity。GMAC不會讓這種事情發生的！
06/28 23:01, 19F
→
06/28 23:02, , 20F
尤其是“修飾語誤植”在AT中被列為主要排錯點的時候,
06/28 23:02, 20F
→
06/28 23:02, , 21F
他們會更加小心的使用這種修飾語
06/28 23:02, 21F
→
06/28 23:17, , 22F
喔~~了解! 1992年虧損 但一直到2001才又虧損~ 感謝!
06/28 23:17, 22F
→
06/28 23:18, , 23F
但 and also 的確有其它的是排錯點!
06/28 23:18, 23F
→
06/28 23:19, , 24F
which is dependent on 跟 which depends on
06/28 23:19, 24F
→
06/28 23:20, , 25F
還原後 這兩個事一樣的意思 不過我會想說 動詞優先~
06/28 23:20, 25F
推
06/28 23:26, , 26F
還原不是這樣，形容詞跟分詞修飾的對象不一樣！！
06/28 23:26, 26F
→
06/28 23:27, , 27F
跟動詞優先沒有關係，跟邏輯句意有關細
06/28 23:27, 27F
→
06/28 23:27, , 28F
dependent變成樹它自己依賴自己的size...怪異
06/28 23:27, 28F
→
06/28 23:29, , 29F
depending是“根據它的size...，樹它可以....”
06/28 23:29, 29F
→
06/28 23:55, , 30F
可是字典上說 depedent 也有一樣的意思捏!!! ~~
06/28 23:55, 30F
→
06/28 23:56, , 31F
affected or decided by something 取決於
06/28 23:56, 31F
→
06/28 23:56, , 32F
困惑!
06/28 23:56, 32F
→
06/28 23:57, , 33F
depend 也有依賴的意思~
06/28 23:57, 33F
推
06/29 01:24, , 34F
老實說，一看到A和B，我會選B，因為A和B的vary in無誤，
06/29 01:24, 34F
→
06/29 01:25, , 35F
且A的both...and的用法小誤...但看到C，我會挑C，比B好，
06/29 01:25, 35F
→
06/29 01:25, , 36F
理由有1. depend on = according to，完全符合文意。
06/29 01:25, 36F
→
06/29 01:26, , 37F
2. dependent on有“依賴”或“受...影響/取決於...”的
06/29 01:26, 37F
→
06/29 01:27, , 38F
意思，意思沒有depend on來得精確。
06/29 01:27, 38F
→
06/29 01:29, , 39F
順道一提，看到D應該可以更加肯定B不是GMAT要的答案。:P
06/29 01:29, 39F
推
06/29 16:13, , 40F
問題點是在：dependent修飾的對象--樹。
06/29 16:13, 40F
推
06/29 16:15, , 41F
重點不是dependent是什麼意思，是它所能修飾的對象，會
06/29 16:15, 41F
→
06/29 16:15, , 42F
產生邏輯上的問題。
06/29 16:15, 42F
→
06/29 16:17, , 43F
depending分詞修飾action--根據size...,樹『它可以』
06/29 16:17, 43F
→
06/29 16:19, , 44F
dependent只能修飾名詞--根據它的size,樹....
06/29 16:19, 44F
→
06/29 16:21, , 45F
這樣整個句子就荒謬了。另外，樓上Ｌ大把這兩者意思上
06/29 16:21, 45F
→
06/29 16:21, , 46F
的差異，用中文解釋的非常清楚～
06/29 16:21, 46F
→
06/29 16:23, , 48F
如果原ＰＯ還是有疑慮，看一下 2 a的解釋與例句
06/29 16:23, 48F
‣ 更多 cloudballoon 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1E2S4vEW (GMAT)
GMAT 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 cloudballoon 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1E2S4vEW (GMAT)