[問題] election後的OA修正
近日收到一件美國選取後的OA
但礙於對選取不熟悉
有部分問題想請教各位前輩
1.申請時的請求項
claim 1:一種裝置,含有A,B,C,...(省略三者的連結關係)而C為X製成的.
claim 2:依附claim 1,進一步界定A,B,C的連結關係(對應實施例1)
claim 3:依附claim 1,進一步界定A,B,C的連結關係(對應實施例2)
claim 4:依附claim 1,進一步界定A,B,C的連結關係(對應實施例3)
claim 5:依附claim 1,進一步說明X為X1(X1有記載於實施例1-3)
2.選取回覆
官方來函指出claims 2-4分別說明不同發明,應選擇其中一者續審.選擇實施例1
(claim 2)續審,因此claims 3-5 withdrawn.
3.OA
官方來函指出claims 1,2不具新穎性及進步性.但申請人指出claim 1加上C為X1
製成的整體特徵應可克服此缺失.想請問能否於修正中,將claim 1的X修正為X1?
而我困惑的是:修正後的特徵不就是claim 5嗎?如此的修正是否妥當?或者各位前
輩有更好的建議?
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 58.115.189.137
推
05/18 00:07, , 1F
05/18 00:07, 1F
→
05/18 00:27, , 2F
05/18 00:27, 2F
→
05/18 00:30, , 3F
05/18 00:30, 3F
→
05/18 00:30, , 4F
05/18 00:30, 4F
推
05/18 22:26, , 5F
05/18 22:26, 5F
→
05/18 22:27, , 6F
05/18 22:27, 6F
→
05/18 23:18, , 7F
05/18 23:18, 7F
推
05/18 23:43, , 8F
05/18 23:43, 8F
→
05/19 01:01, , 9F
05/19 01:01, 9F
→
05/19 01:02, , 10F
05/19 01:02, 10F
→
05/19 01:03, , 11F
05/19 01:03, 11F
→
05/19 01:05, , 12F
05/19 01:05, 12F
推
05/19 20:13, , 13F
05/19 20:13, 13F
→
05/19 20:13, , 14F
05/19 20:13, 14F
→
05/19 20:14, , 15F
05/19 20:14, 15F
→
05/19 20:15, , 16F
05/19 20:15, 16F
→
05/19 20:15, , 17F
05/19 20:15, 17F
→
05/19 20:17, , 18F
05/19 20:17, 18F
→
05/19 20:17, , 19F
05/19 20:17, 19F
→
05/19 20:18, , 20F
05/19 20:18, 20F
推
05/19 21:28, , 21F
05/19 21:28, 21F
推
05/19 22:24, , 22F
05/19 22:24, 22F
→
05/20 01:12, , 23F
05/20 01:12, 23F
Patent 近期熱門文章
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章