Re: [問題] 幫忙審國外的論文...
皇家學會月報叫我打勾勾的項目：
（勾yes/no/unsure）
1. Is the subject appropriate for the journal?
2. Is the content sufficiently significant to warrant publication in MNRAS?
3. Are the methods and results set out clearly?
4. Are all the necessary references given?
5. Is the summary sufficiently informative?
6. Can the paper be shortened without loss of clarity?
7. Are all the figures and tables necessary?
8. Are the figures and tables adequate?
9. If there are colour figures, is colour reproduction essential? If so
for which figures? Please leave details in the comments box below.
10. Is the paper in reasonable English?
11. If the paper contains long tables, finding charts etc., can these be
published in electronic form only?
12. Do you want your name revealed to the authors?
不過，期刊與博碩士論文當然有不同的標準，而以上這些，如果不能
做到85%以上都是yes，大概也沒膽量投出來。所以到了這種等級，真
正有意義的審查意見也不會包含在上面那些只用打yes/no的部份裡。
--
用星光作畫的男孩 他的夜晚比白天燦爛
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.109.176.58
推
01/02 19:35, , 1F
01/02 19:35, 1F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 4 之 5 篇)：
2
7
PhD 近期熱門文章
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章