[討論] 2025初的AI程式工具實際上會降生產力
https://secondthoughts.ai/p/ai-coding-slowdown
ycombinator 的討論
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44526912
其實都是討論這篇,"衡量 2025 年初人工智慧對經驗豐富的開源開發人員生產力的影響 "。
https://metr.org/blog/2025-07-10-early-2025-ai-experienced-os-dev-study/
ycombinator 的討論
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44522772
full paper
https://metr.org/Early_2025_AI_Experienced_OS_Devs_Study.pdf
看討論,蠻有趣,各種理由解釋或不信。
但這研究還蠻紮實的。16個人,246個任務。
https://i.meee.com.tw/dkmxs57.png

很有趣的是,每個人都預估生產力有增加,包含開發者本身。開發者寫完後還是認為生產力有增加,但實際生產力是下降的。
個人是ai是有幫助的,但真的限定在某些非常特定情況。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 36.224.192.162 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Soft_Job/M.1752217454.A.82F.html
※ 編輯: oopFoo (36.224.192.162 臺灣), 07/11/2025 15:05:56
推
07/11 16:25,
2周前
, 1F
07/11 16:25, 1F
→
07/11 16:27,
2周前
, 2F
07/11 16:27, 2F
→
07/11 16:28,
2周前
, 3F
07/11 16:28, 3F
→
07/11 16:28,
2周前
, 4F
07/11 16:28, 4F
→
07/11 16:30,
2周前
, 5F
07/11 16:30, 5F
→
07/11 16:31,
2周前
, 6F
07/11 16:31, 6F
→
07/11 16:32,
2周前
, 7F
07/11 16:32, 7F
推
07/11 16:34,
2周前
, 8F
07/11 16:34, 8F
→
07/11 16:35,
2周前
, 9F
07/11 16:35, 9F
推
07/11 16:40,
2周前
, 10F
07/11 16:40, 10F
→
07/11 16:40,
2周前
, 11F
07/11 16:40, 11F
→
07/11 16:51,
2周前
, 12F
07/11 16:51, 12F
→
07/11 16:51,
2周前
, 13F
07/11 16:51, 13F
→
07/11 16:52,
2周前
, 14F
07/11 16:52, 14F
→
07/11 16:55,
2周前
, 15F
07/11 16:55, 15F
→
07/11 16:56,
2周前
, 16F
07/11 16:56, 16F
推
07/11 17:00,
2周前
, 17F
07/11 17:00, 17F
→
07/11 17:00,
2周前
, 18F
07/11 17:00, 18F
→
07/11 17:02,
2周前
, 19F
07/11 17:02, 19F
推
07/11 17:19,
2周前
, 20F
07/11 17:19, 20F
→
07/11 17:19,
2周前
, 21F
07/11 17:19, 21F
推
07/11 18:08,
2周前
, 22F
07/11 18:08, 22F
→
07/11 18:27,
2周前
, 23F
07/11 18:27, 23F
推
07/11 18:34,
2周前
, 24F
07/11 18:34, 24F

推
07/11 18:41,
2周前
, 25F
07/11 18:41, 25F
推
07/11 19:00,
2周前
, 26F
07/11 19:00, 26F
→
07/11 19:00,
2周前
, 27F
07/11 19:00, 27F
→
07/11 19:00,
2周前
, 28F
07/11 19:00, 28F
→
07/11 20:53,
2周前
, 29F
07/11 20:53, 29F
→
07/11 21:00,
2周前
, 30F
07/11 21:00, 30F
→
07/11 21:02,
2周前
, 31F
07/11 21:02, 31F
→
07/11 21:05,
2周前
, 32F
07/11 21:05, 32F
→
07/11 21:30,
2周前
, 33F
07/11 21:30, 33F
→
07/11 23:43,
2周前
, 34F
07/11 23:43, 34F
→
07/11 23:44,
2周前
, 35F
07/11 23:44, 35F
→
07/11 23:44,
2周前
, 36F
07/11 23:44, 36F
→
07/12 00:42,
2周前
, 37F
07/12 00:42, 37F
→
07/12 00:58,
2周前
, 38F
07/12 00:58, 38F
→
07/12 00:59,
2周前
, 39F
07/12 00:59, 39F
→
07/12 00:59,
2周前
, 40F
07/12 00:59, 40F
→
07/12 03:56,
2周前
, 41F
07/12 03:56, 41F
→
07/12 03:58,
2周前
, 42F
07/12 03:58, 42F
→
07/12 03:58,
2周前
, 43F
07/12 03:58, 43F
推
07/12 05:28,
2周前
, 44F
07/12 05:28, 44F
→
07/12 05:28,
2周前
, 45F
07/12 05:28, 45F
推
07/12 23:29,
2周前
, 46F
07/12 23:29, 46F
推
07/12 23:47,
2周前
, 47F
07/12 23:47, 47F
→
07/12 23:48,
2周前
, 48F
07/12 23:48, 48F
→
07/12 23:49,
2周前
, 49F
07/12 23:49, 49F
→
07/12 23:51,
2周前
, 50F
07/12 23:51, 50F
→
07/12 23:52,
2周前
, 51F
07/12 23:52, 51F
→
07/12 23:56,
2周前
, 52F
07/12 23:56, 52F
推
07/13 06:04,
2周前
, 53F
07/13 06:04, 53F
→
07/13 06:04,
2周前
, 54F
07/13 06:04, 54F
→
07/13 06:04,
2周前
, 55F
07/13 06:04, 55F
推
07/13 06:27,
2周前
, 56F
07/13 06:27, 56F
→
07/13 08:10,
2周前
, 57F
07/13 08:10, 57F
→
07/13 08:12,
2周前
, 58F
07/13 08:12, 58F
→
07/13 08:14,
2周前
, 59F
07/13 08:14, 59F
→
07/13 08:15,
2周前
, 60F
07/13 08:15, 60F
→
07/13 08:17,
2周前
, 61F
07/13 08:17, 61F
推
07/13 09:00,
2周前
, 62F
07/13 09:00, 62F
→
07/13 09:01,
2周前
, 63F
07/13 09:01, 63F
→
07/13 09:02,
2周前
, 64F
07/13 09:02, 64F
→
07/13 09:03,
2周前
, 65F
07/13 09:03, 65F
→
07/13 09:04,
2周前
, 66F
07/13 09:04, 66F
→
07/13 09:05,
2周前
, 67F
07/13 09:05, 67F
→
07/13 09:06,
2周前
, 68F
07/13 09:06, 68F
→
07/13 09:06,
2周前
, 69F
07/13 09:06, 69F
→
07/13 09:07,
2周前
, 70F
07/13 09:07, 70F
推
07/13 09:09,
2周前
, 71F
07/13 09:09, 71F
→
07/13 09:10,
2周前
, 72F
07/13 09:10, 72F
推
07/13 10:51,
2周前
, 73F
07/13 10:51, 73F
→
07/13 10:51,
2周前
, 74F
07/13 10:51, 74F
→
07/13 10:52,
2周前
, 75F
07/13 10:52, 75F
→
07/13 10:52,
2周前
, 76F
07/13 10:52, 76F
推
07/13 10:54,
2周前
, 77F
07/13 10:54, 77F
→
07/13 10:54,
2周前
, 78F
07/13 10:54, 78F
→
07/13 10:54,
2周前
, 79F
07/13 10:54, 79F
→
07/13 10:54,
2周前
, 80F
07/13 10:54, 80F
推
07/13 11:33,
2周前
, 81F
07/13 11:33, 81F
→
07/13 11:33,
2周前
, 82F
07/13 11:33, 82F
推
07/13 13:20,
2周前
, 83F
07/13 13:20, 83F
→
07/13 13:20,
2周前
, 84F
07/13 13:20, 84F
推
07/13 14:57,
2周前
, 85F
07/13 14:57, 85F
→
07/13 14:57,
2周前
, 86F
07/13 14:57, 86F
→
07/13 14:57,
2周前
, 87F
07/13 14:57, 87F
推
07/13 20:13,
2周前
, 88F
07/13 20:13, 88F
→
07/13 20:14,
2周前
, 89F
07/13 20:14, 89F
→
07/13 20:14,
2周前
, 90F
07/13 20:14, 90F
推
07/13 20:18,
2周前
, 91F
07/13 20:18, 91F
→
07/13 20:18,
2周前
, 92F
07/13 20:18, 92F
→
07/13 20:18,
2周前
, 93F
07/13 20:18, 93F
→
07/14 02:26,
2周前
, 94F
07/14 02:26, 94F
→
07/14 02:27,
2周前
, 95F
07/14 02:27, 95F
推
07/14 03:20,
2周前
, 96F
07/14 03:20, 96F
→
07/14 09:40,
2周前
, 97F
07/14 09:40, 97F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇):
Soft_Job 近期熱門文章
100
789
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章
-4
17