[題目] 關代

看板TOEIC (TOEIC多益)作者 (莎里奈)時間12年前 (2013/10/11 16:35), 編輯推噓0(0015)
留言15則, 3人參與, 最新討論串1/4 (看更多)
※ [本文轉錄自 Eng-Class 看板 #1ILcgu_o ] 作者: saininniang (莎里奈) 看板: Eng-Class 標題: [文法] 關代 時間: Thu Oct 10 16:50:15 2013 一、 He is the novelist ___ they say is one of the best writers of today. 答案 ___ = who 我寫whom,因為我認為 they say him is one........ --- 受詞 help~~~~~ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 1.164.8.128

10/10 17:19, , 1F
they say [who is one of the best..] who當主詞
10/10 17:19, 1F

10/10 17:19, , 2F
say的受詞是後面整個句子 所以they say也不是接him而是he
10/10 17:19, 2F

10/10 17:22, , 3F
The answer is who, not whom.
10/10 17:22, 3F
無法理解 一般來說,題目大都為 He is the novelist ___ is one of the best writers of today. 如果是上句,我會寫who 但題目插入了 they say 兩個字 He is the novelist who they say is one of the best writers of today. --- ---- 主詞 主詞 ==> 語法很怪 我舉例其它題目來說 This is the boy whom we met at station yesterday. ---- 同上,原本題目應也為whom He is the novelist whom they say is one of the best writers of today. ----- 至於解答、推文版友都是who,我還是不能理解,help~~~~~~~ ※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:35) ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ※ 轉錄者: saininniang (117.56.64.35), 時間: 10/11/2013 16:35:51 ※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:36) ※ 編輯: saininniang 來自: 117.56.64.35 (10/11 16:36)

10/11 17:20, , 4F
是不是看到who 接著不是they say 而是 is one of
10/11 17:20, 4F

10/11 17:20, , 5F
這樣對你來說比較好理解??
10/11 17:20, 5F

10/11 17:21, , 6F
they say 感覺是另一個插入句
10/11 17:21, 6F

10/11 17:21, , 7F
省略了一個 that, 而那個 who 是為求清楚表達代表誰
10/11 17:21, 7F

10/11 17:21, , 8F
所以以省略為前提 they say that he is....
10/11 17:21, 8F

10/11 17:22, , 9F
that 可以省略 he 用 who代替 提到novelist後面
10/11 17:22, 9F

10/11 17:22, , 10F
這只是我的猜測就是了
10/11 17:22, 10F

10/11 17:22, , 11F
因為以你的理解 say 後面通常接人
10/11 17:22, 11F

10/11 17:23, , 12F
說錯 接事 以that 去帶出來的N子句
10/11 17:23, 12F

10/11 17:23, , 13F
要是也是 they say that he is....
10/11 17:23, 13F

10/11 18:33, , 14F
我問你 你會說 They say he is the best writer
10/11 18:33, 14F

10/11 18:33, , 15F
還是They say him is the best writer? 不言而喻
10/11 18:33, 15F

10/11 18:35, , 16F
至於你給的例子,We met him at station yesterday
10/11 18:35, 16F

08/06 16:08, , 17F
that 可以省略 h https://noxiv.com
08/06 16:08, 17F

09/07 02:30, , 18F
因為以你的理解 say https://daxiv.com
09/07 02:30, 18F
文章代碼(AID): #1ILxXefr (TOEIC)
討論串 (同標題文章)
文章代碼(AID): #1ILxXefr (TOEIC)