[單字] satire和irony 何不同?

看板Eng-Class (英文板)作者 (是八)時間15年前 (2010/07/30 23:19), 編輯推噓2(2024)
留言26則, 6人參與, 最新討論串1/1
遇到一個文章的問題如下 the writer uses ﹍﹍ to make his point. a) satire b) irony c) parody d) allegory 這教材沒附答案的 當時上課時教師是說答案 b 窩查一下 satire 諷刺,諷刺文章 irony 諷刺 parody 諷刺詩文 究竟為什麼要b阿? i will never understand the middle-class attitude to paid employment. Someone asked me the other day if i enjoyed my work; (1)___was all i could do not laugh in his face. i don't think i can properly explain to you how offensive his remark was, but it is a question simultaneously (2)___to my basic belief in the sanctity of doing nothing and utterly beyond my capacity to answer. Of course i don't (3)___my work! I did't get where i am today by "enjoying work".I find the whole idea of "enjoying work" utterly disgusting. Work isn't to be enjoyed, it is to be (4)___.I am proud to say I have never enjoyed a day's work in my life, (5)___ do I have any intention of ever doing so. I would as soon enjoy a day at work as i would enjoy the (6)___ we got at school whenever an important person visited the country. Some of us still have (7)___, you know. 1. a) that b) it c) this d) there 2. a) offensive b) amusing c) agreeable d) close 3. a) do b) hate c) enjoy d) understand 4. a) evaluated b) endured c) experienced d) criticized 5. a) and b) or c) so d) nor 6. a) assignment b) day off c) reward d) concert 7. a) principles b) ideas c) prejudice d) power -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 112.105.66.31

07/31 00:06, , 1F
這得看原文章這麼寫才能判斷
07/31 00:06, 1F

07/31 00:07, , 2F
irnoy很像中文的反諷,會說一個完全與事實相反的東西
07/31 00:07, 2F

07/31 00:07, , 3F
on
07/31 00:07, 3F

07/31 00:10, , 4F
satire 和parody都是指「文體」,是整篇都充滿諷刺意味
07/31 00:10, 4F

07/31 00:10, , 5F
irony只是其中某句用到而已 又parody通常帶著幽默口吻
07/31 00:10, 5F

07/31 00:20, , 6F
其實我感覺4個都可耶~
07/31 00:20, 6F

07/31 00:23, , 7F
對啊只有這一句一定四個都可以XD
07/31 00:23, 7F

07/31 00:46, , 8F
若要細辨acd都是xx文/作品(work), b是手法/形式
07/31 00:46, 8F

07/31 02:46, , 9F
這個會不會不是文法題,而是閱讀題? XDDDDD
07/31 02:46, 9F

07/31 02:48, , 10F
不過就算是閱讀題也很難....因為satire本來就帶有irony
07/31 02:48, 10F

07/31 02:49, , 11F
,satire也可以用parody的方式,要細分其實有點困難...Orz
07/31 02:49, 11F

07/31 03:53, , 12F
這個是一個克漏字文章 下面出5-10個克漏字項目 之後又一道
07/31 03:53, 12F

07/31 03:54, , 13F
類似閱讀測驗的全面問題 問文章內涵之類的
07/31 03:54, 13F

07/31 03:55, , 14F
這是那文章的最後一題 都固定一題閱讀測驗這樣
07/31 03:55, 14F
※ 編輯: g418 來自: 112.105.66.31 (07/31 04:33)

07/31 04:36, , 15F
當時檢討的答案是bacbdba
07/31 04:36, 15F

07/31 06:12, , 16F

07/31 06:12, , 17F
(注意讀開頭的部分) 比如"全民大悶鍋"這一類的(genre/form
07/31 06:12, 17F

07/31 06:13, , 18F
就是satire. 他們有用到irony這一個元素/呈現手法
07/31 06:13, 18F

07/31 06:13, , 19F
原文章如果是這樣子寫那麼就是satire-> 比如他寫Obama總統
07/31 06:13, 19F

07/31 06:14, , 20F
(是真的有這政治人物)被問到說他是否enjoy his work, 然後
07/31 06:14, 20F

07/31 06:15, , 21F
他馬上打電話給前總統Bush(也是真的有這政治人物).....然
07/31 06:15, 21F

07/31 06:16, , 22F
後點點點叉叉叉(你自己套用全民XXX那短劇的演出/呈現方式)
07/31 06:16, 22F

07/31 06:17, , 23F
但是原文章真的是作者自己所做的表示,且也不是反應社會
07/31 06:17, 23F

07/31 06:18, , 24F
(or諷刺社會的某種現象) 他只是用irony的方式表達他對某
07/31 06:18, 24F

07/31 06:18, , 25F
一問題的觀點/想法
07/31 06:18, 25F

08/12 15:19, , 26F
謝謝教答
08/12 15:19, 26F
文章代碼(AID): #1CKkrbUL (Eng-Class)
文章代碼(AID): #1CKkrbUL (Eng-Class)