PTT職涯區 / EngTalk (全英文聊天)

[Talk] BSO responses the Boston bomb

看板EngTalk (全英文聊天)作者 (1234)時間12年前 (2013/05/01 10:12), 編輯推噓2(2推 0噓 23→)
留言25則, 2人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
Boston Symphony Orchestra hanged a banner on the street, to response the tragedy happened several weeks ago: “This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before.” --Leonard Bernstein I do have some thoughts, not related to Boston bomb though. What causes violation? There must be a trigger like a poverty gap, uneven educational levels, high unemployment rate or stagnation, and so on. Can music really impair those social problems, or just heal the people who afford expensive concert tickets? I don’t mean that Boston Symphony Orchestra doesn’t serve the poor. However, no matter how loudly you blow your horn, if it doesn’t connect the people, it cannot offer a real healing power to the society. Contrarily, music becomes a label of social class. No offense, Mr. Bernstein. -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 128.125.25.40 ※ 編輯: reedy 來自: 128.125.25.40 (05/01 10:14)
推
05/01 10:48, , 1F
yeah, unless they perform free of charge in public
05/01 10:48, 1F
→
05/01 12:31, , 2F
That is not the answer. It is not about the music.
05/01 12:31, 2F
→
05/01 12:32, , 3F
This is about, how do those people feel.
05/01 12:32, 3F
→
05/01 12:32, , 4F
Those who might cause another VIOLENCE.
05/01 12:32, 4F
→
05/01 12:34, , 5F
How do low-class people think, when they see the banner?
05/01 12:34, 5F
→
05/01 15:12, , 6F
it is the boston bombing that what you quote responds
05/01 15:12, 6F
→
05/01 15:12, , 7F
to, however, the bombing is terroist attack, right?
05/01 15:12, 7F
→
05/01 15:13, , 8F
then what does this kind of terrorist attack has to do
05/01 15:13, 8F
→
05/01 15:13, , 9F
with the social problems or inequalities you mentioned
05/01 15:13, 9F
→
05/01 15:13, , 10F
above?
05/01 15:13, 10F
→
05/01 21:44, , 11F
Well, I said, my thought is not related to the Bomb.
05/01 21:44, 11F
→
05/01 22:46, , 12F
but Bernstein was referring to the tragedy, and you
05/01 22:46, 12F
→
05/01 22:46, , 13F
referred to Bernstein and his music. your train of
05/01 22:46, 13F
→
05/01 22:47, , 14F
thought just confused me @@
05/01 22:47, 14F
→
05/01 23:35, , 15F
I didn't refer to the "music" at all.
05/01 23:35, 15F
→
05/01 23:39, , 16F
Truth is, the one actually needs music to wash the
05/01 23:39, 16F
→
05/01 23:39, , 17F
dust in their mind, always sits outside the auditorium.
05/01 23:39, 17F
→
05/01 23:50, , 18F
Either the poor or terrorist, they are not in.
05/01 23:50, 18F
→
05/01 23:54, , 19F
i am not so sure terrorists aren't in or wouldn't in
05/01 23:54, 19F
→
05/02 03:00, , 20F
No problem. Either the terrorists sit in and nothing is
05/02 03:00, 20F
→
05/02 03:00, , 21F
changed, or they are not willing to sit in to be changed
05/02 03:00, 21F
→
05/02 03:01, , 22F
by music. There is always something wrong.
05/02 03:01, 22F
→
05/02 03:02, , 23F
Again, music is always good and powerful, but it cannot
05/02 03:02, 23F
→
05/02 03:02, , 24F
approach the one who actually needs it. That's problem.
05/02 03:02, 24F
推
05/02 07:37, , 25F
ok, thanks for sharing
05/02 07:37, 25F
‣ 更多 reedy 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HW7eDVs (EngTalk)
EngTalk 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 reedy 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1HW7eDVs (EngTalk)