Re: [問題] May I say ~

看板chatskill (溝通談話技巧)作者 (新竹林志玲)時間6年前 (2018/03/13 11:08), 編輯推噓0(005)
留言5則, 1人參與, 6年前最新討論串2/3 (看更多)
Hello,everyone~ Could you help me to correct the sentence below: "Always asking the female classmate who was next to him for a candy!" https://www.hopenglish.com/understandingrelativepronouns?ref=category 這裡不是這個網站裡所提到的第2種情況.. 因為這裡的結構是:關代+"be V",(後面沒有"現分/過分"), 是第3種情況:關代後直接接上V(於此為"be V":"was"), 省略時將V改寫為"現分(V-ing)",所以 who was next to him ===> being next to him 可是我聽到的都是"next to him", 而不是"being next to him"! 誰可以導正我的盲點! > < ※ 引述《howisfashion (新竹林志玲)》之銘言: : Hello,everyone~ : Could you help me to correct the sentence below: : "Always asking the female classmate who was next to him for a candy!" : and could I show it by, : "Always asking the female classmate being next to him for a candy!" : Thanks a lot! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 123.195.38.127 ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/chatskill/M.1520910528.A.539.html

03/13 11:11, 6年前 , 1F
你的問題在於把be動詞視為動詞,它具有動詞的特性沒錯,但
03/13 11:11, 1F

03/13 11:12, 6年前 , 2F
是在這裡因為後面加上形容詞片語,所以我會把它寫成單純用
03/13 11:12, 2F

03/13 11:12, 6年前 , 3F
形容詞片語去形容名詞,而不是形容詞子句。
03/13 11:12, 3F

03/13 11:13, 6年前 , 4F
如果原句是who was being next to hime的話,表示強調存在
03/13 11:13, 4F

03/13 11:13, 6年前 , 5F
的being,我就會保留它。
03/13 11:13, 5F
文章代碼(AID): #1Qfq30Kv (chatskill)
討論串 (同標題文章)
本文引述了以下文章的的內容:
以下文章回應了本文
完整討論串 (本文為第 2 之 3 篇):
文章代碼(AID): #1Qfq30Kv (chatskill)