[問題] 高二英文選擇題

看板teaching (教材板)作者 (蘋果臉)時間13年前 (2011/11/17 18:22), 編輯推噓10(1004)
留言14則, 9人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
上次幫家教學生上課解題 學生問了一題我也答不出來原因的題目 因此很不好意思來請教各位有經驗的朋友們 :) 題目如下: She would not go with us, ________________________. A) if it were not your suggestion B) was it for your suggestion C) were it not for your suggestion D) had it not been for your suggestion 正確答案為C,但學生問A為什麼不行 要如何解釋答案為什麼選C 還有A為什麼是錯的呢? 麻煩大家了,謝謝 :] -- /* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* * ﹡* ﹡∕" ▇▇◣ 。 . 【我是蘋果女孩。 . " ' . 。 . 。 . ○ 。 . I'm 愛波費斯。 ˙ ○ " ◢◢ . . " ○ . . . ' . ˙ ' 。 " ' . . ewornirl ""_ _ ◤▼* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* ﹡* * ﹡* -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 112.104.159.237

11/17 18:25, , 1F
if it were not "for" your suggestion..
11/17 18:25, 1F

11/17 18:27, , 2F
推樓上L大 確實是少了"for"
11/17 18:27, 2F
謝謝樓上兩位的回答 那請問要如何解釋答案為什麼選C呢 ? 還有請問少了"for",差別在哪裡呢? 謝謝 :) ※ 編輯: newborngirl 來自: 112.104.159.237 (11/17 18:34)

11/17 19:39, , 3F
if it were not for N=Were it not for N 高中句型
11/17 19:39, 3F

11/17 19:41, , 4F
少了for意思差很多 仔細想一下就會了解了
11/17 19:41, 4F

11/17 20:19, , 5F
要不是“因為”你的建議 所以要有for
11/17 20:19, 5F

11/18 01:09, , 6F
謝謝大家的詳細說明 :)
11/18 01:09, 6F

11/18 05:34, , 7F
你看出來A少了for嗎?少了for意思就不對了
11/18 05:34, 7F

11/18 05:39, , 8F
抱歉一時沒看到前面推文:)
11/18 05:39, 8F

11/19 12:58, , 9F
那...有人能有A選項造出句子嗎? ;-)
11/19 12:58, 9F

11/19 12:59, , 10F
11/19 12:59, 10F

11/19 16:11, , 11F
if it were not your suggestion, then what the hell
11/19 16:11, 11F

11/19 16:11, , 12F
would it be?
11/19 16:11, 12F

11/19 22:35, , 13F
哈哈哈哈哈!! 樓上害我笑慘了!!
11/19 22:35, 13F

11/20 00:00, , 14F
屌~~
11/20 00:00, 14F
文章代碼(AID): #1EnE1Jnr (teaching)
討論串 (同標題文章)
文章代碼(AID): #1EnE1Jnr (teaching)