[轉錄] SOA給分的標準

arbitrageur

原文在 http://www.actuary.ca/phpBB/viewtopic.php? t=8344&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=25 先講非選擇題的評分標準，必看：兩篇作者都是C5Funus From both Carmody and someone in my organization who has served as a grader, I understood that each question has a certain number of "grading outline points". One need not get all the grading points to get a 10 on that question. For example, for a particular question there might be 50 grading points, but the number of points for a 10 on that specific question might be 35. Carmody stresses this point in his seminar -- you don't need to write everything on the grading outline to get a 10 on the question -- often the "main bullet points" might comprise 30-40% of the total grading points on a particular question. The important thing is to get on paper (at a pace of 3 minutes per question point) these "main points", include some detail, and move on. If you leave a question completely blank on a written exam, it's so deadly, because you can get a fair amount of the points needed to get a 10 on a question by writing just the key things. Since this is a timed exam, there clearly is "decreasing marginal utility" to writing polished and detailed answers for any particular question. I think this also explains why people tend to get either individual question scores of 1, 2, or 10. 所以答非選擇題時千萬要注意這篇文章中講的重點。 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The method the SOA uses to set the pass mark is a secret that is as closely guarded as the formula for Coca Cola. I always understood that the grade that you receive on the exam only indicates where you finished relative to the pass mark. 0 = less than 50% of the pass mark 1 = 50-59% of the pass mark 2 = 60-69% of the pass mark 3 = 70-79% of the pass mark 4 = 80-89% of the pass mark 5 = 90-99% of the pass mark 6 = 100-109% of the pass mark 7 = 110-119% of the pass mark 8 = 120-129% of the pass mark 9 = 130-139% of the pass mark 10 = at least 140% of the pass mark 大家知道成績單上的6分是怎麼來的了吧？至於幾分的原始分數會被訂成6分，則是由委員會的成員們決定。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.csie.ntu.edu.tw) ◆ From: 140.112.243.239