Re: [Ask ] When can I skip the word "that"

看板EngTalk (全英文聊天)作者guiltyself (schuldig)時間12年前 (2013/08/01 12:37)推噓1(1推 0噓 0→)

留言1則, 1人參與討論串2/2 (看更多)

Hi basically, both sentences you made can't ignore or skip the word "that". the first sentence actually mentioned two cities and two systems the system in the city and the system in teh suburban. if you skip the word "that" the sentence will be like this: The system in the city is better than xxx in the suburban. but exactly WHAT in the suburban, you have to put the word system in the blank, but anyway you already know that you can switch it into "that". therefore, this "that" represent the system IN THE SUBRUBAN. you have to bring it up. the second sentence "i like the girl who has the red hair" well, grammatically, it should be "i like the girl who has red hair", or "i like the girl who is red-haired." i'm not a professional english teacher, therefore i couldn't offer you with a exact formula of this. but here's my tip to see if the word "that" is ignorable: first, neglect the part of the sentence after relative words, for example, "i like the girl". ok, it makes sense, you like the girl. then think about this, red hair is like an extra explination attached to this girl, in this case, you put "who" to add up a second clause to enrich the sentence, therefore, the sentence is able to contain two verbs, (you do realize that usually only one verb can happen in a single sentence.) IF you skip the word "that" this sentence will become one clause with two verbs which is not acceptable, (well, most of the time) in conclusion, check if the sentence has two verbs, if there are, check if Subjects, objects and verbs can be easily confused without that. if it doesn't make any difference, then it's ok to skip it well, most of the time. ※ 引述《pdsc (BigFisH)》之銘言： : Hello, I'm learning and got a question which no one can answer for me. : Sometimes, we use "what", "which", "that", "when" and so on to add more : discription to explan the things we want to say. However, as I know, sometimes : those words can be skipped. I am confused with that how to distinguish the : sentances which can skip those words or not? Are there any rule can be fulfill? : And which way of providing sentances is formal? or informal? : EX: : The system in the city is better than (that) in the suburban. : I like the girl (who) has the red hair. : Thanks for helping me!!! -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 220.135.57.163