[請益] 英文題目一題已刪文

看板Teacher (教師)作者 (joyluck)時間11年前 (2014/12/01 15:27), 編輯推噓8(809)
留言17則, 7人參與, 最新討論串1/1
一題國一題目 ______ my gifts under the table? (A) Are (B) Are those 答案是A 就教B為何錯, 直敘句Those are my books under the table. 英文老師覺得是ok的句子嗎? 謝謝回應! -- Sent from my Android -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 42.77.215.236 ※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Teacher/M.1417418874.A.620.html

12/01 15:28, , 1F
答句是: Yes, they are.
12/01 15:28, 1F

12/01 16:54, , 2F
B的話要those就不要my,指示形容詞重複了
12/01 16:54, 2F

12/01 17:43, , 3F
但是直敘句是Those are my books...所以應沒重複的
12/01 17:43, 3F

12/01 17:45, , 4F
如果問句的意思是"桌下的禮物是我的嗎?"
12/01 17:45, 4F

12/01 17:46, , 5F
應該是Are those gifts under the table mine?
12/01 17:46, 5F

12/01 17:51, , 6F
The books under the table are mine(my books).
12/01 17:51, 6F

12/01 23:41, , 7F
直述句裡的those是指示"代名詞",不一樣喔
12/01 23:41, 7F

12/02 10:28, , 8F
兩個都對。A的情境是不知道有沒有禮物所以詢問,B是
12/02 10:28, 8F

12/02 10:28, , 9F
已經知道禮物在那但是要確定是他的。
12/02 10:28, 9F

12/02 10:30, , 10F
就像小孩子問:A-我的禮物在桌子底下嗎?B-桌子底下
12/02 10:30, 10F

12/02 10:30, , 11F
的禮物是我的嗎?
12/02 10:30, 11F

12/02 13:14, , 12F
原PO是否可能把There are(有)和Those混淆了?
12/02 13:14, 12F

12/02 18:29, , 13F
不是耶,就是題目是____my gifts under the table?
12/02 18:29, 13F

12/02 18:29, , 14F
Yes, they are.
12/02 18:29, 14F

12/02 18:30, , 15F
選項:(A)are(B)are those
12/02 18:30, 15F

12/02 20:02, , 16F
b的回答應是yes, those are.
12/02 20:02, 16F

12/03 08:30, , 17F
樓上你………
12/03 08:30, 17F
文章代碼(AID): #1KV1XwOW (Teacher)
文章代碼(AID): #1KV1XwOW (Teacher)