[考題] 關於原因自由行為碰上客體錯誤的問題
看板Examination (國家考試)作者a525263412 (YAYA~)時間13年前 (2013/08/19 23:41)推噓4(4推 0噓 28→)留言32則, 7人參與討論串1/2 (看更多)
[考題] 國考歷屆考題與考題觀念討論(書裡看到的選這個)請附上想法、出處
黑道老大甲教唆乙去殺仇人丙，乙為了壯膽而喝酒，陷入酩酊狀態之後衝往丙家，
卻將丙之子丁誤為丙而殺之
這是我在撲馬老師的書裡看到的一題
就乙來說
解答上是寫 例外說是認為殺人既遂
前置說和先行行為說會認為是過失致死
似乎例外說是採法定符合說
前置說和先行行為說是採具體符合說
請問要怎麼推論才會得出這種結果啊？
謝謝大家> <!！
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.47.233.224
推
08/19 23:49, , 1F
08/19 23:49, 1F
→
08/19 23:50, , 2F
08/19 23:50, 2F
→
08/19 23:52, , 3F
08/19 23:52, 3F
→
08/19 23:58, , 4F
08/19 23:58, 4F
→
08/19 23:58, , 5F
08/19 23:58, 5F
→
08/20 00:01, , 6F
08/20 00:01, 6F
→
08/20 00:02, , 7F
08/20 00:02, 7F
→
08/20 00:59, , 8F
08/20 00:59, 8F
→
08/20 00:59, , 9F
08/20 00:59, 9F
→
08/20 01:00, , 10F
08/20 01:00, 10F
→
08/20 01:02, , 11F
08/20 01:02, 11F
→
08/20 01:02, , 12F
08/20 01:02, 12F
→
08/20 01:03, , 13F
08/20 01:03, 13F
→
08/20 01:04, , 14F
08/20 01:04, 14F
→
08/20 01:05, , 15F
08/20 01:05, 15F
→
08/20 01:06, , 16F
08/20 01:06, 16F
→
08/20 01:06, , 17F
08/20 01:06, 17F
→
08/20 01:08, , 18F
08/20 01:08, 18F
→
08/20 01:12, , 19F
08/20 01:12, 19F
→
08/20 01:14, , 20F
08/20 01:14, 20F
推
08/20 01:15, , 21F
08/20 01:15, 21F
推
08/20 01:15, , 22F
08/20 01:15, 22F
→
08/20 01:16, , 23F
08/20 01:16, 23F
→
08/20 01:17, , 24F
08/20 01:17, 24F
→
08/20 01:18, , 25F
08/20 01:18, 25F
→
08/20 01:18, , 26F
08/20 01:18, 26F
→
08/20 01:19, , 27F
08/20 01:19, 27F
推
08/20 10:54, , 28F
08/20 10:54, 28F
→
08/20 10:54, , 29F
08/20 10:54, 29F
→
08/21 14:17, , 30F
08/21 14:17, 30F
→
08/21 14:19, , 31F
08/21 14:19, 31F
→
08/21 14:25, , 32F
08/21 14:25, 32F
討論串 (同標題文章)
以下文章回應了本文：
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇)：
Examination 近期熱門文章
PTT職涯區 即時熱門文章
40
168