Re: [語文] SC- so that 慣用語請教

看板GMAT (GMAT入學考試)作者dukechiang (go go go)時間16年前 (2009/09/22 22:10)推噓1(1推 0噓 0→)

留言1則, 1人參與討論串2/3 (看更多)

對於that 是不是會被誤認為a recording system關代作題時我也思考過這點我的想法有二第一, 如果that有修飾a recording system的嫌疑其實也不是不可以若仔細讀這題可以發現即使that用來modify a recording system語意上也是對的因為子句中連Theodore也不知道的就是 a recording system 即使用來做關代也不會有語意上的差別第二 a recording system 基本上在這不會有關代的嫌疑 a recording system that even Theodore did not know "it" existed. " it"就已經破解 that是 a recording system 的迷思 that若作關代整句寫法應該是 a recording system that Theodore did not even know or system whose existence was not known even for Theodore or existence of a recording system that even Theodore did not even know 類似這種寫法跟遑論E選項是倒裝的寫法 that是關代的疑慮是不太可能的我真的很質疑Gmac所謂的文法上的錯是指怎樣的錯??? : : 2. So ....that可否用在倒裝句上??? : : 58. < A recording system was so secretly installed and operated in the Kennedy : : Oval Office that> even Theodore C．Sorensen，the White House counsel，did not : : know it existed． : : (A) A recording system was so secretly installed and operated in the : : Kennedy Oval Office that : : (B) So secret was a recording system installation and operation : : in the Kennedy Oval Office : : (C) It was so secret that a recording system was installed and operated : : in the Kennedy Oval Office : : (D) A recording system that was so secretly installed and operated in : : the Kennedy Oval Office : : (E) Installed and operated so secretly in the Kennedy Oval Office was : : a recording system that : : Ans. A : : 當然A是沒有問題 so. that正確用法 : : 我想問的是E的倒裝句模式為何不可以 : : 下列是有關OG對E選項解釋 : : E The inverted word order does not grammatically fit into : : the rest of the sentence : 這題的關鍵字是在grammtically上，我想了很久為什麼文法會有錯？ : 我的猜測是，so...that結構中，that應該是做為名詞子句的連接詞， : 但是在這邊that會誤為關係代名詞， : a recording system that even ... didn't know it existed : 所以主要子句只有兩個分詞installed and operated而沒有動詞，因此文法上錯誤 : 同樣的，如果是這樣，我覺得OG的解釋寫成會造成ambiguity也許比較合理 : : 那為何介下來這題又可以解釋so that是可以用在倒裝句 : : GWD5-Q1: : : < So dogged were Frances Perkins’ investigations of the garment : : industry, and her lobbying for wage and hour reform was persistent>, Alfred : : E. Smith and Franklin D. Roosevelt recruited Perkins to work within : : the government, rather than as a social worker. : : A:and her lobbying for wage and hour reform was persistent, : : B:and lobbying for wage and hour reform was persistent, so that : : C:her lobbying for wage and hour reform persistent, that : : D:lobbying for wage and hour reform was so persistent, : : E:so persistent her lobbying for wage and hour reform, that : : Ans. E : : 這個例句似乎有可以解釋倒裝句行式是ok!! : : 我的想法是難道so that 用來修副詞時不可用到裝但用在修飾形容詞就可以使用??? : : 若不然就是 Gmac自己出題出到自相矛盾??? : : 以上這幾點想請問一下大家的意見感謝!!! : 承上，這題的that前面有comma，that當關代時是不可以用在非限制子句的 : 因此就沒有被誤會成關代的問題 : 做這題的時候我想了一陣子，A跟E的文法都是完全沒錯的，句意也沒有問題 : 這題我最後是出大絕招「唸唸看」XD : 然後就選E了 : 前一題也是一樣，E選項其實文法「也可以」沒有錯， : 但是在有可能有誤會的情況下，就沒有A好了 : 這兩題我沒有問老莫的原因是，我覺得這就好像 : 床前明月光 VS 月光照床前 : 兩個文法都沒有錯，句意也都沒有改變， : 但是你問到文學素養好的美國人，他們怎麼選都是會選GMAC給的那個答案 : (我真的有拿去問native speaker...) : 好像今天一個外國人問我們床前明月光那兩句為什麼前一句比較好 : 沒有為什麼啊～～～ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 58.114.84.146